Cinncinati/Xavier plays

[zm1283]

9:46 - block/charge

9:32 - Should be a decent continuous motion play to discuss.

If anyone can clip these it would be appreciated.

[BlueDevilRef]

Originally Posted by zm1283

9:46 - block/charge



9:32 - Should be a decent continuous motion play to discuss.



If anyone can clip these it would be appreciated.

Cmon ZM, you better than that dude! You didn't say which half!

[JRutledge]

Play #1: 9:46 - block/charge



Play #2: 9:32 - Should be a decent continuous motion play to discuss



Peace

[zm1283]

Originally Posted by BlueDevilRef

Cmon ZM, you better than that dude! You didn't say which half!

Whoops.

Thanks, JRut.

[Blindolbat]

1. Good call
2. Eh. Definitely with a hop after initial contact and before shot goes up. Probably shouldn't have counted it but in full speed I can see it.

[MechanicGuy]

Play 1 is basically about as close as it gets.

Did the defender stop moving forward before the offensive player left the ground to catch the pass? I looked at in slo-mo and still can't decide

Announcer is dead wrong though. He's got the ball, you don't have to give a chance to a damn thing (other than touch the floor if you got there late). Live, I probably would've had a block too.

Very difficult play to officiate too, unless you're disciplined enough to stare at the empty lane in your PCA with a trap 3 feet away from you.

[Nevadaref]

The block/charge play is close. Did the defender establish his position prior to the offensive player going airborne? It is tough to tell even with the video. The offensive player doesn't come down on the floor either. He lands on the defender's foot and then crashes into him.
Difficult play, but I call a charge when it is super close.

The other play is not even close. Only MTD and the guy working the game would count the goal. Cinci/Xavier? Perhaps its an Ohio thing.

[ODog]

Agreed that Play 1 is essentially as close as it gets. I can go either way. In real time, I'd likely have called a block.

Play 2, no goal. I agree he was fouled in his initial shooting motion (which is when the official raises his fist and blows his whistle), but THEN he reloads after the defender goes by/play is blown dead. Yes, it's a tough sell to award 2 shots and not count the goal, but that is how I see this one. Player was prevented from finishing his initial motion by the foul ... and then decided to try again unimpeded after the whistle.

[bob jenkins]

I think the second play is much tougher than the first. I have an easy block on the first. I can see either on the second but would lean toward counting the basket.

Now I'll go back and watch the slo-mo versions.

[JRutledge]

Play #1: I have a block. The defender is still coming forward when the player goes airborne. It was not that hard of a call IMO. Saw that when I first saw the play.

Play #2: I guess it depends on when the foul was called. I am thinking he did not actually call the foul until the player was coming down from the air and grabbed the shooter. If you feel the contact was before that, then you do not have a counted basket. I can see both sides but understand that the official is standing and seeing the left arm as well that we do not see. I would like to ask him what he had ultimately, which is not likely going to happen.

Peace

[zm1283]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

Play #1: I have a block. The defender is still coming forward when the player goes airborne. It was not that hard of a call IMO. Saw that when I first saw the play.

Play #2: I guess it depends on when the foul was called. I am thinking he did not actually call the foul until the player was coming down from the air and grabbed the shooter. If you feel the contact was before that, then you do not have a counted basket. I can see both sides but understand that the official is standing and seeing the left arm as well that we do not see. I would like to ask him what he had ultimately, which is not likely going to happen.

Peace

Agree on both. I was 50/50 on the second one when I saw it but I don't think he had a foul until later in the sequence when the defender came down on top of the shooter. It wouldn't be popular but I am okay with counting the basket.

[Bad Zebra]

Both are razor thin margins either way....

1) I like block here...my gut reaction first time in real time. Looks to be moving forward slightly in slow-mo. Certainly wouldn't question a charge from the official though.

2) Shooter appears to have gathered and started up at point of contact. Count it.

[Rich]

Depends on what the lead is calling on #2. We're seeing a bump that he may have passed on and held the whistle and called a foul later in the sequence.

I've been known to hold a whistle during prolonged contact until I'm certain that I'm going with a foul and then it might be during the shot whereas if I'm fast with my whistle (which is never desirable) it comes much earlier in the sequence.