Brain cramp

[Nevadaref]

Note that swinging elbows is a violation. The rule is simply that violations make the ball dead, but fouls do not.
I agree with your determination that the try counts, if you deemed that offensive BI did not occur.

[BigCat]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Note that swinging elbows is a violation. The rule is simply that violations make the ball dead, but fouls do not.
I agree with your determination that the try counts, if you deemed that offensive BI did not occur.

Yes, it's just ads backwards that we will cancel a try in flight etc because of violation but a T has no effect. I thought through the question I was asked, I just don't like the answer. I would write and pass a rule that says a T by offense causes dead ball immediately.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by BigCat

Yes, it's just ads backwards that we will cancel a try in flight etc because of violation but a T has no effect. I thought through the question I was asked, I just don't like the answer. I would write and pass a rule that says a T by offense causes dead ball immediately.

The rule already says that.

There's just no "offense" (or "team control") during a try.

[BigCat]

Originally Posted by Adam

The rule already says that.

There's just no "offense" (or "team control") during a try.

Yes, id have to change the exception for fouls occurring while try in flight. Technical fouls by Thrower for goal or teammate make ball dead. No exception. I will put you in charge of the wording changing the exception....