|
|||
Quote:
|
|
|||
There is nothing more technical than by rule this is a BC violation. In reality it won't and shouldn't get called.
__________________
in OS I trust |
|
|||
There's also the question of which official would even get a good look at it.
R (or the tossing official) is in the best position, but probably won't be looking over there until players clear the jump circle. In a 3-person game, neither of the umpires is going to be in a good position to see it... U1 might have a chance. In a 2-person game, the U would probably get a look (assuming she hasn't moved off the division line yet). Personally, I'm no-calling this, but I'm also not going to attempt to overrule a partner if they call it. |
|
|||
Quote:
I agree with the poster who stated that a 2-person crew is actually better positioned to make this call than a 3-person crew. |
|
|||
I agree 100%.
Do you really want to start a game by calling this? I don't want to be that guy. Is not calling it technically wrong? I suppose so, but I'm not calling it. Play on and let's get the game going. |
|
|||
100% correct. Don't be the guy that wants to show how great he knows the rules and call this. Play on!
|
|
|||
Why shouldn't it get called if it's witnessed by an official who knows the rules and knows it's a violation?
|
|
|||
So you call a 3 second violation as soon as you hit a 3 count?
__________________
in OS I trust |
|
|||
Quote:
|
|
|||
Quote:
Seriously, I don't see why one wouldn't call this if one was sure -- but I certainly see how one might well not be sure, both because it happens quickly and because it isn't one of things one is thinking about during a jump. (And, I suppose, because there are so few jumps in the modern game that there aren't a lot of chances to see the weird stuff actually happen.) |
|
|||
This will be my last foray into this topic. Those on the "if I see it I must call it" do you warn and or T a coach when they step out of the coaching box?
Do you call 3 seconds at 3 and 10 second FT at 10? The reality of this play is that it's not getting called. It's so close do you really want to start the game with this hair to split? I'm not calling the play that is in this video a BC violation.
__________________
in OS I trust |
|
|||
Quote:
With regards to the time-based examples you give, the time itself is somewhat subjective and both of those rules have had plenty of press on what they were really intended to address and it isn't just the location or even the time. Both are targeted at unfair advantages (big man under the basket) or borderline unsportsmanlike behavior or unreasonably delaying the game (refusing to shoot a FT). As for the T on the coach, no. Same reason, not how it was intended to be handled. Personally, I don't shy away form calling something because it is close, I call things because they're the right thing to call. We're paid to split those hairs and not calling it is merely splitting the hair the other way.
__________________
Owner/Developer of RefTown.com Commissioner, Portland Basketball Officials Association Last edited by Camron Rust; Tue Nov 29, 2016 at 05:46pm. |
|
|||
Quote:
I doubt any coach would know it was a violation and I doubt anybody in the crowd would either. Do we really want to blow the whistle one second into the game for this? I don't. |
Bookmarks |
|
|