Seton Hall/Xavier continuous motion (video request)

[JetMetFan]

Block called with 0:29.0 left in 2nd half. Was ruled a non-shooting foul.

[JetMetFan]

Fine, fine. I'll answer my own request (I was going to bed when I made the OP )

[Hugh Refner]

If this was NBA, definitely continuation. If NFHS, then no. NCAA, flip a coin.

In my opinion, it was not continuation. I don't think his arm movement with the ball when the whistle was blown was part of starting a shot.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Hugh Refner

If this was NBA, definitely continuation. If NFHS, then no. NCAA, flip a coin.

In my opinion, it was not continuation. I don't think his arm movement with the ball when the whistle was blown was part of starting a shot.

The rule in the NBA is basically the same as the NF rule.

NCAA is only different because they require an upward motion.

Peace

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Hugh Refner

If this was NBA, definitely continuation. If NFHS, then no. NCAA, flip a coin.

In my opinion, it was not continuation. I don't think his arm movement with the ball when the whistle was blown was part of starting a shot.

NFHS and NBA rule is just about the same. NCAA-M is more restrictive.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

[JetMetFan]

Doesn't upward motion only apply to an airborne shooter? The illegal contact in this play was before the BH/D left the floor.

Also, after a quick scan of the NCAAM rule book I don't see the word "upward" used in connection with airborne shooter situations.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by JetMetFan

Doesn't upward motion only apply to an airborne shooter? The illegal contact in this play was before the BH/D left the floor.

Also, after a quick scan of the NCAAM rule book I don't see the word "upward" used in connection with airborne shooter situations.

We've been told to interpret upward motion as the beginning of the shot.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

[Bad Zebra]

Looks like a non-shooting common foul to me. Upward motion started a full step after initial defensive contact IMO...however, the "gather" took place right at contact. What do you want to use as the start of the "habitual throwing movement"?

[Nevadaref]

Forget upward motion, that's a charging foul.
Why is the Lead jumping on this play? This is the C's call. It is a primary defender from above the FT line. Watch the movement of the C after the whistle. I believe that he is going the other way.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Forget upward motion, that's a charging foul.
Why is the Lead jumping on this play? This is the C's call. It is a primary defender from above the FT line. Watch the movement of the C after the whistle. I believe that he is going the other way.

Good thing that the L saved the C, cause that would've been a horrible call, IMO.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Forget upward motion, that's a charging foul.
Why is the Lead jumping on this play? This is the C's call. It is a primary defender from above the FT line. Watch the movement of the C after the whistle. I believe that he is going the other way.

Originally Posted by Rich

Good thing that the L saved the C, cause that would've been a horrible call, IMO.

I feel there is some legitimacy in Nevada's point.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I feel there is some legitimacy in Nevada's point.

Eh, I don't. I don't think the defender kept LGP.

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Watch the movement of the C after the whistle. I believe that he is going the other way.

Didn't notice as I watched it live. Yeah, C was loading up to ship that the other way.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Rich

Eh, I don't. I don't think the defender kept LGP.

But if you throw yourself into the defender, LGP may not apply.

Peace

[Rich]

He's past the defender, who bumps him from behind. I just don't see how you put this on the offensive player...