2013 World Series Thread

[scrounge]

Originally Posted by Mountaincoach

When I see issues like this, I think about what the lasting legacy of something like that could be in either direction. If they let the call stand, the name of the umpire who made the call becomes a household name for decades as the "guy who blew such an easy call, yada yada". If the call is discussed and overturned in a meeting of the man's peers (which happened), it becomes the topic of conversation for about the next 24 hours until Game 2 is played, and the umpire goes on to live his life in peace and continue with his career. I say BRAVO to all of the people involved. They got the call correct. The pressure that has historically been applied to baseball umpires to maintain autonomy and not ask for help is just simply too much.

Yep, this was a "lead on Sportscenter" kind of call, as in if they don't reverse such an egregious miss, it's the lead on Sportscenter and the start of a new meme. That doesn't mean every close play has to be huddled - indeed, there were other close plays in that game. But that wasn't just a whale of a miss, it was a brontosaurus.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by scrounge

But that wasn't just a whale of a miss, it was a brontosaurus.

Whales (Blue):
Length - 70-90 feet (21-27 m) long
Weight - 120 tons (109 tonnes)

Brontosaurus:
Length - 70-90 feet (21-27 m) long
Weight - 33-38 tons (30-35 tonnes)

[scrounge]

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn

Whales (Blue):
Length - 70-90 feet (21-27 m) long
Weight - 120 tons (109 tonnes)

Brontosaurus:
Length - 70-90 feet (21-27 m) long
Weight - 33-38 tons (30-35 tonnes)

Clearly I was referring to beluga whales!

well done