"Dislodged" or not

[bigda65]

NFHS,

R1, ball hit to F5, boots, but finally throws to F4 who drops the ball.
R1 has slid well past 2nd, but on his way by, grabs the base and it comes up from the square mounting hole. The base is still in the mounting hole and is leaning slightly toward left field. (the base is still in the area of where it should be, it is just not flush with the ground) F4 picks up the ball and tags the runner before he gets back to the bag.

U1 calls R1 out on the tag. PU and U1 confer, U1 reverses call and puts R1 back on 2nd. No real argument either way and game continues.

Would the base be considered dislodged in this sitch??

[ozzy6900]

If the base is still in the mounting hole, I would not rule as a dislodged base. The actual base is still in the area unlike if the base were sitting 3 feet away.

[mbyron]

Even if it's dislodged he's out.

[dash_riprock]

That's an out.

[Rich Ives]

Originally Posted by mbyron

Even if it's dislodged he's out.

OMG - another FED different call.

In FED the runner can't be tagged if the base slides away from him.

In OBR and NCAA the runner cannot be played on if he is touching the spot where the base bag should be.

Which makes more sense?


LL lets the runner chase the base too - makes sense at the lower levels.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by bigda65

NFHS,

R1, ball hit to F5, boots, but finally throws to F4 who drops the ball.
R1 has slid well past 2nd, but on his way by, grabs the base and it comes up from the square mounting hole. The base is still in the mounting hole and is leaning slightly toward left field. (the base is still in the area of where it should be, it is just not flush with the ground) F4 picks up the ball and tags the runner before he gets back to the bag.

U1 calls R1 out on the tag. PU and U1 confer, U1 reverses call and puts R1 back on 2nd. No real argument either way and game continues.

Would the base be considered dislodged in this sitch??

I would not.

[bigda65]

PU told BU that you can't have an out when the base is dislodged.

So I guess it boils down to your interp of dislodged in FED.

[dash_riprock]

Rich quoted the FED Rule. The base did not slide away from the runner. He's out.

[jicecone]

"F4 picks up the ball and tags the runner before he gets back to the bag.

He's out!!!

[dileonardoja]

R1 Over slid the base. Dislodging, if anything helped him hold on longer! He is OUT