4th Out Appeal

[MrUmpire]

Originally Posted by Rich Ives

I asked two questions:

You mean I can't say, in one sentence, "I'm appealing that R2 and R3 both left early"?

And I, aprpropriately sticking to the informatin of the OP, rhetorically asked:

"Is that what he (the coach in the OP said?"

You expect me to believe that's not valid?

If the coach had so clearly appealed as you phrased it, I believe it would be valid.

My read of the post is that he did not.

And BTW yes, in the original OP I really think he was appealing both runners.

I don't. The umpire at the time didn't. It even appears that the coach didn't.

He, at best, asked a rule question, which could have been a precursor to an appeal.