Malicous contact question

[Jay R]

Question about malicious contact rule. Baseball Canada rules. R2 is trying to score on a single to RF. The catcher is right in front of the plate when the throw from RF sails over the catcher to the backstop. The catcher jumps to try to catch the throw and lands on the plate. R2 puts his shoulder down and runs over the catcher. The plate umpire called R2 safe and then threw him out of the game for malicious contact. There was no argument from either side but we started to wonder after the game if R2 should have been out. The contact occurred just as he was touching the plate. How do you rule that?

[GA Umpire]

Depends on rule set. Some say if it occurs after the runner touches the plate, score the run and eject him.

Others say runner is out and eject him.

Canada rules? Does that equate to OBR? If it does and no local rules say otherwise, then score the run and eject the runner.

It all depends upon the rules being played under.

[Ump29]

If contact occurs after the runner crosses the plate, eject. If contact occurs at or before the plate , runner is out and ejected. As taught in Canada for Baseball Canada Rules.

[Rich Ives]

Originally Posted by GA Umpire

Depends on rule set. Some say if it occurs after the runner touches the plate, score the run and eject him.

Others say runner is out and eject him.

Canada rules? Does that equate to OBR? If it does and no local rules say otherwise, then score the run and eject the runner.

It all depends upon the rules being played under.

Baseball Canada has OBR rules modifications. The MC rule is one of them.

[jicecone]

He shoots, he scores!

Good solid check there, eh.

Tells us what Canadian rules are and we can give you a better answer, eh.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by jicecone

He shoots, he scores!

Good solid check there, eh.

Tells us what Canadian rules are and we can give you a better answer, eh.

Okay, Hoser....take off, eh! Here is a link to the rules and mechanics of Baseball Canada, okay, eh?

Baseball Canada Umpires

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

Okay, Hoser....take off, eh! Here is a link to the rules and mechanics of Baseball Canada, okay, eh?

Baseball Canada Umpires

Thanks eh.

But I I got de puck in de head too many times eh, and have troubles reading doze words der, eh!!

Actually eh, I don't care about no canadian baseball anyway eh.

But tank u der big boy.. EH.............