Update on "But is he a Smitty?"

[waltjp]

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

I'm thinking that after the award became a national controversy...it was a good idea to take the award back.

Still, it doesn't excuse their poor judgement in the first place. Can you really expect to put the genie back in the bottle?

[johnnyg08]

I agree with you waltjp

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

I agree with you waltjp

So do I, which makes taking it back even worse than giving it in the first place!

[johnnyg08]

another good point...even though it looks crappy...taking the award back was the right thing to do. either way it made national news...

[JJ]

Sort of cheapens all of those award that organization gave out previously....I don't know if I'd keep mine....too bad...

JJ

[johnnyg08]

Why would you give it back? The molester award aside...often times there are situations where people feel that somebody doesn't deserve an award for whatever reason. again, the molester award aside.

I see what you're saying JJ, but I don't quite understand how your award would be cheapened because they stupidly gave an award to somebody who is in the .0000000001% of our umpire circle...those who deservedly earned the award...have placed their individual value on that specific award. thoughts?

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

Why would you give it back? The molester award aside...often times there are situations where people feel that somebody doesn't deserve an award for whatever reason. again, the molester award aside.

What molester award? I thought they gave him an award for his umpiring service.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

if they give the damn award to a convicted child molester...what do you think the name of the award should be?

Uh....the Umpire Lifetime Achievement Award?

[Forest Ump]

Originally Posted by JJ

Sort of cheapens all of those award that organization gave out previously....I don't know if I'd keep mine....too bad...

JJ

That reminds me of the Nobel Peace Prize. If they can give one to Al Gore it can't be much of an award.

[mbyron]

That was an AP story. I'm glad it got picked up in Miami. I wonder whether CT cared at all.

[dash_riprock]

Originally Posted by Forest Ump

That reminds me of the Nobel Peace Prize. If they can give one to Al Gore it can't be much of an award.

They gave one to Jimmy Carter too, which I think makes Lou Piniella eligible automatically.

[Hemibee]

Originally Posted by JJ

Sort of cheapens all of those award that organization gave out previously....I don't know if I'd keep mine....too bad...

JJ

I have to agree with JJ, on first glance it would appear to cheapen all the others since they gave the award knowing what this person is.

[JRutledge]

I do not see how this cheapens anything. The people wanted to honor a person and made a mistake. If I had received an award or was a member, I might not be happy, but I would not be give back awards or resign just because of this incident. I am not personally responsible for the actions of other people.

Peace

[greymule]

That reminds me of the Nobel Peace Prize. If they can give one to Al Gore it can't be much of an award.

The Peace Prize is the joke of the Nobels. Even Yasir Arafat got one.