Saw this today...

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by mbyron

I don't understand. Where was the sub for Charles batting? I suppose the coach wanted to DH for the sub and move Zak to the 3-spot. No can do, coach.

Ordinarily, at the time BOO was discovered I should think that Zak is an improper batter, and that the sub for Charles should come up with Zak's 1-1 count. Zak would be the next batter, and the DH role is eliminated for the remainder of the game.

Sneaky rat, but I don't see any outs here.

There's no BOO, it's an illegal sub. 2-36-3d.

Zak (the illegal sub) is out and restricted to the dugout. 3-1-1

David bats next (unless Zak's out was the third out) and a new player enters the lineup in the thrid spot (formerly occupied by Charles).