Joe West Does IT AGAIN

[Rich Ives]

Originally Posted by PFISTO

Well he did it again with another bad call at 2nd. Now I realize that it wasn't as bad as the last time but come on Joe can't you make believe that you enjoy what your doing and move a little instead of just standing there and ho hum your out. Man that make's it so hard to look up to him as an example let alone buy his equiptment. Come on Joe move your #$# and maybe bend a little. And Yes I am a Yankee Fan.

Methinks it was Gerry Davis last time.

[johnnyg08]

me thinks Gerry Davis...but that's just me...

[Rich Ives]

On both calls the fielder partially blocked the umpire's view of the play.

Infielders come inside on stolen base attempts most of the time.

The "conclusive" replay is almost always the one from the outfield side.

So why doesn't U2 stay outside so he doesn't get blocked out?

In the "old days" the AL umps were outside and the NL umps inside. How was it decided that inside was the better position?

[johnnyg08]

good points...I have never worked 4 man, but what you're saying makes sense when I think about the replays I've seen in MLB regarding missed calls at 2B

[Kaliix]

It burns my *** that an MLB umpire again blew a call on a steal at second because he was meandering his way over to second, never came set and never adjusted his angle to get the proper look. Granted this wasn't as close as the Gerry Davis gross miss, but the runner was clearly out.

It is one thing to hustle, be in the right position, adjust to get the best angle you can and just miss a call. But there is no reason for the piss poor mechanics mechanics and just outright laziness that I have seen displayed by MLB umpires this year.

Is it too much to ask of them that they act like they care. Well paid professional umpires shouldn't miss calls because they can't bother to get in position. That is what amateur umpires are for! ;-\

[kylejt]

I'm waiting for the MLB umpire groupies here to tell the rest of us these guys have earned the right sit in a Barkalounger and call a game.