Catch? Out?

[BigUmp56]

Originally Posted by PWL

Way to cut and paste to try and suit your needs. You only make your self look foolish when do this. Anyone with a pulse sees right through you. As long as you have your legion behind you, you feel safe in your assertion that your right. Believe me I have spoken to the esteemed Mr. Evans and he described that a fair ball only need to be touched and a foul ball should be caught. I've asked anyone to feel free to contact the man for his exact varification. Admit it the two rules do not jive together as written. I feel it is something to be look into for clarification.

I quoted your posts in the exact order they were presented as you responded. My "legion" is anyone with a firm understanding that you're not all that brushed up on the rules. That would include nearly every umpire on this site. Did you even discuss the situation where the ball is deflected and subsequently caught by another fielder over foul territory with Evans? You'd be lying if you said you did, if you're not already lying when you say you spoke to him in the first place.



Tim.