LL Rules - appealing an out at home plate

[LDUB]

Originally posted by CoachJM
Everybody at the game saw him stop on his way back to 1B ... But I'm pretty sure he saw the same thing everybody else did.

So you admit that you had nothing to protest. Maybe with the play at third, the BU had no idea if R1 tagged up, so he ruled safe. The PU probally saw that R1 never even got close to retouching first, so he told the BU this after the appeal happned.

Originally posted by CoachJM
You rarely contribute anything meaningful to a rules discussion (although when you do, you do seem to know what you're talking about - at least in regard to FED rules).

When was the last time there was a rules discussion? A few months ago on a balk thread which went for many pages.

Originally posted by CoachJM
The vast majority of your posts are simply whines about other peoples' posts. It's a free country, so if that's what floats your boat, I certainly don't have a problem with it. But why bother? Just curious.

You could say that about anyone, except Bob Jenkins.