Old Time Religion - Judgement Calls

[Bfair]

Warren Willson (quoted):
OBR 2.00 Definition of ILLEGAL "Illegal (or illegally) is contrary to these rules."

OBR 9.02(a) "Any umpire's decision which involves judgement ... is final."

Referee Magazine November 1992 "...a judgement decision by rule cannot be changed..."

Carl's complete list of 5 would not fall within this reasoning, Warren. However, you support Carl's list of 5.

As Dave points out, you are remaining inconsistent in your logic and arguments. Not surprising as of late. You will have difficult time winning this argument while remaining consistent. Please decide which you will choose to do.

Just my opinion,

Steve
Member
EWS