Free Kick Out of Bounds

[Scuba_ref]

K muffs the kick out of bounds or the kick accidently contacts K and then bounces out of bounds - kick out of bounds infraction?

R muffs kick then K muffs kick and then ball goes out of bounds - kick out of bounds infraction?

In both cases the kick has not ended. I can't find anything other than the situation where R muffs the kick out of bounds which is not a foul.

Am I right or missing something here?

Thanks

[CT1]

Originally Posted by Scuba_ref

(Play 1) K muffs the kick out of bounds or the kick accidently contacts K and then bounces out of bounds - kick out of bounds infraction?

(Play 2) R muffs kick then K muffs kick and then ball goes out of bounds - kick out of bounds infraction?

In both cases the kick has not ended. I can't find anything other than the situation where R muffs the kick out of bounds which is not a foul.

Am I right or missing something here?

Thanks

The foul is for a free kick going OOB untouched by R.

So, you're right in Play 1, wrong in Play 2.

[Scuba_ref]

Thank you.

I also just found 6.1.8 SITUATION B which has R muff the kick and then K touch the kick before it rolls out of bounds. Ball to team R at the out of bounds spot.

[maven]

6-1-8: "A free kick shall not be kicked out of bounds between the goal lines
untouched inbounds by R."

[Robert Goodman]

Originally Posted by Scuba_ref

K muffs the kick out of bounds or the kick accidently contacts K and then bounces out of bounds - kick out of bounds infraction?

NFL yes, NCAA & Fed no.

R muffs kick then K muffs kick and then ball goes out of bounds - kick out of bounds infraction?

NFL yes, NCAA & Fed no.

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by Robert Goodman

NFL yes, NCAA & Fed no.

Incorrect on the first.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by robert goodman

nfl, ncaa & fed yes.

nfl yes, ncaa & fed no.

fify

[Robert Goodman]

Originally Posted by Welpe

Incorrect on the first.

No, I'm right on the 1st. It's not a foul in NFL if team R is last to touch it before it goes out of bounds, otherwise it's a foul. The situation described was one where team R was not last to touch it. But now that I look at it, I was incorrect on the last (NCAA & Fed), which should've been "yes"; when I first read it, I hadn't noticed that R apparently hadn't touched the ball at all.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by Robert Goodman

No, I'm right on the 1st. It's not a foul in NFL if team R is last to touch it before it goes out of bounds, otherwise it's a foul. The situation described was one where team R was not last to touch it. But now that I look at it, I was incorrect on the last (NCAA & Fed), which should've been "yes"; when I first read it, I hadn't noticed that R apparently hadn't touched the ball at all.

Trolling? Or reading problem...

"NFL yes, NCAA & Fed no" is the wrong answer for the first situation. It is YES for all three. This is what Welpe (and I) told you. Converting the 2 situations into 4 by splitting up the words doesn't make you right - it makes you a troll. You decide.

[Robert Goodman]

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn

Trolling? Or reading problem...

"NFL yes, NCAA & Fed no" is the wrong answer for the first situation. It is YES for all three. This is what Welpe (and I) told you. Converting the 2 situations into 4 by splitting up the words doesn't make you right - it makes you a troll. You decide.

Sorry, not trying to troll. I see what you meant now. When you quoted just one situation and I answered for different rule sets, I assumed that by "first" you meant my answer, "NFL yes".

Part of the problem here is that there's no nesting of quotes in the automatic quoting feature.

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by Robert Goodman

Sorry, not trying to troll. I see what you meant now. When you quoted just one situation and I answered for different rule sets, I assumed that by "first" you meant my answer, "NFL yes".

I was unclear. I meant you were incorrect on the first scenario.

[Texas Aggie]

it makes you a troll

Please stop with the troll BS. He isn't a troll.

If you think someone is really a troll, THEN DON'T RESPOND. That will eliminate the issue.