Quote:
Originally Posted by EsqUmp
Sounds like a lot of people are really saying, "As long as the runner does 'what she is supposed to,' there isn't interference."
Should we apply this to R1 who runs in a straight line directly into F4 fielding a batted ball? Her "act" is running. Colliding with F4 isn't an "act" it is just a consequence of her "non-act" of running, according to the logic we hear.
So if F6 dives for a ball that just gets by her, is she immediately committing obstruction on R2 (assuming she was actually hindered) because she is no longer in the "act" of fielding a batted ball?
Seems to be a lot of contradiction and applying the "what's she supposed to do " philosophy, that so many argue against.
|
Rich....please moderate this post......this is not a whose **** is longest just so you know. But, I thought since you have known me since about 1997, you can add some credibility to what I am fixin to say.
EsqUmp is still beating his dead horse.......Jeez...You have been proven wrong so many times.....why do you even still argue it....? You should go to your other NY expert and have him find that his BB Expert Carl Childress agrees with US. Even though it has no bearing on the SB game.
Arguing for interference when there is none is insane.
Dakota, Steve, Irish, Tom, NCAA, Manny, myself and many other hundreds of other umpires
(who I wish I could all name) have butted heads for years arguing about the most trivial of things..........all the way back to the 90's......and we for the
pretty much part kept it civil.
You show up in the last two years and proclaim yourself God's gift to umpires. And if we did not adhere to your view of umpiring....we were idiots. Time and time again we show you where you are wrong....and you act like a Teflon Don.....you allow the shit to roll right off of you.
Excuse me if I am not impressed.
Ooooooh.....you are an NCAA umpire.
Get in line. I can out umpire about 99% of y'all in ASA ball.....and probably most others in NCAA....even with a shitty hip.
PM me for my pedigree.....
Joel