Quote:
Originally Posted by Adam
I agree with BNR (I would have had the travel).
On #5, I don't think the defender moves into the path, he's already in it and adjusts slightly within the path, so I'm not penalizing him by calling a block.
|
Agreed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by icallfouls
flop
flop
no call
no call
charge - offense spread legs so that either leg was on each side of defender then goes through
no call
|
I'd like to hear rationale for why moving toward and under an airborne shooter resulting in that much contact is a no-call.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JetMetFan
I got a little skeptical when I saw plays 3 and 6 in real-time because the defender went down as though he was hit by a sniper rifle. I'm not saying they're not PCs but I'm saying I might have passed on them since the force with which he hit the deck didn't seem to match the force of the contact, which would've made me think he flopped.
|
On #3 there seems like a little embellishment but still clearly a PC IMO. On play #6 it looks like he got rtfo. Not seeing it there.
And for ballgame99 I'd like to know what you see the defender doing wrong to consider blocks on plays #3 and #6. I think you and icallfouls need tutorials on refereeing the defense bases on your responses here.