Quote:
	
	
		
			
				
					Originally Posted by  MrUmpire
					 
				 
				When FED removed the accidental appeal from the rule book they neglected to delete that  situation from the casebook.  Elliot Hopkis acknowledged that fact and issued a statement that that ruling was no longer accurate. He issued a statement again the next year when that situation still appeared in the book 
 
Why it remains unedited to this date is a mystery, but the fact is the accidental appeal has been removed from the rule book, and that was a POE at the time. 
			
		 | 
	
	
 This is correct. You can X out that case play if you like: it is no longer a valid ruling.