NYY v BO
Anybody else think this runner should have been called out for a basepath violation on this play?
|
Quote:
Joel |
Quote:
It just looked like a violation because of how far behind home plate Ichiro ended up when he passed it. But he was already to the right of the foul line a good distance as he approached. |
Quote:
http://thebiglead.fantasysportsven.n...-1-10-8-12.gif Joel |
Not even close. At the time of the tag, he took one step away with his left foot and almost all of his momentum was forward. Hard to come up with 3 feet there.
|
Quote:
IMO, he is out of the BP, but this is the MLB and sometimes it seems what is real and what is an ESPN clip are two different things :D |
Quote:
That's a tough sell. It's unreasonable to me to expect the runner to turn on a dime like that to go to home, given his direction and momentum. He would have to move more than 45-degrees towards the plate and into the tag. |
Correct me if I'm Wrong
but, doesn't the rule book say (and I don't have one in front of me) that once a tag is attempted the runner must stay in the basepath in a direct line from where he is at the time of the tag all the way to the base? I think based on that I'd have to call him out.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
If Wieters was chasing Ichiro from behind, then he would have been in violation. But because the tag attempt was virtually instantaneous, Ichiro would have had to take a quick right turn from the point of the tag to violate the rule. |
Could there have been an appeal for a missed base?
Suppose the O's catcher tags the plate while making some motion/indication that he is (live ball) appealing a missed base. Would you have an out?
And no, I'm not asking about the "accidental appeal" of touching the plate while trying to tag the runner (which almost happened). |
Quote:
Is it different in softball? |
Quote:
That would be a great heads up play, but then again, they are catcher's for a reason. |
Quote:
I don't have access to my softball rules right now, so I'm soliciting a rule citation under ASA, NFHS, and/or NCAA that would support your claim. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:44am. |