Originally Posted by DaveASA/FED (Post 850382) You weren't the only one that doesn't do college out there. I know of at least two others that do not umpire college ball that were there!

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA (Post 850404) I'm trying to figure out the relevance of whether the umpire works college ball or not.

Originally Posted by Big Slick (Post 850376) That appears to be one fine plate umpire.

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA (Post 850404) I'm trying to figure out the relevance of whether the umpire works college ball or not.

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA (Post 850404) I'm trying to figure out the relevance of whether the umpire works college ball or not.

Originally Posted by Big Slick (Post 850460) There was a statement made about "holding zones." As was relayed by the staff, when all three umpires are "in" (meaning no umpire chased), there "is no holding zone" (the quotes here reflect an actual quote). Therefore, (as not demonstrated in the video) with no runners on or a runner on first: on a base hit, the PU trails the BR, then should take a position at third. No holding zone, just calling position. NCAA mechanics allow the PU to utilize the holding zone in front of the circle for the same play.

Originally Posted by CecilOne (Post 850462) What about the "route" getting there, through the RHB or left of catcher?

Originally Posted by Big Slick (Post 850465) That's also an "NCAA thing" as it doesn't matter. I can assure you this plate umpire is getting on with age and has lost a step or two (but can cut quite the rug under the right circumstances). ASA's clarified position is not through any particular batter's box, just to the left of the catcher. If the catcher moves up the line, you could go through the RHBB.

Originally Posted by mbcrowder (Post 850481) What am I missing ... the RHBB IS to the left of the catcher...

Originally Posted by ronald (Post 850503) They seem to be the ones who have issues with asa 's way of doing things. I guess i made an jack without realizing it. One of the guys bit his tongue as he went to the three umpire mechanic manual and says it reads holding zone a few times. He even stated the words are use in the dad in the3 pump section.

In the 2012 Umpire Manual there is a wording mistake in the Three Umpire System in a few sections. These are, with a runner on 2B only, 1B and 2B, 2B and 3B and Bases Loaded in the sections of Ground Ball to the Infield, and Base Hit to the Outfield. The verbiage used in the Umpire Manual for the movement of the Plate Umpire in these situations is “Move out from behind the plate toward the “holding zone” in foul ground and read the play. As we all know there is no holding zone in a Three Umpire System so the wording could be misleading. It was originally used to describe the plate umpire moving out toward 3B or what we refer to as the holding zone. In these situations the DVD says, “The Plate Umpire should move out from behind the plate and read the play.” These are the words that will be changed in the 2013 Umpire Manual.

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA (Post 850476) Well, to me, the RHBB is just a matter of some lines in the dirt and is more of an issue in SP than fast. I think the key is to avoid getting caught up with the catcher, or as a snappy rug-cutter, the batter-runner leaving the plate area.

Originally Posted by AtlUmpSteve (Post 850531) To me, the only distinction is that a lot of clinicians (yep, me included) urge umpires to go to the left around the RHBB; NOT because you might interfere with the catcher, but because batters often dig enough out of the batters' box to leave a hole where the PU can turn an ankle.