Uf-asu

[flipper]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

BTW, why you are at it, whatever it is, I believe JK called what he saw. I don't call that kicking a call. Was it the wrong call? From different angles, it seemed to be, but from the RHBB, it probably didn't seem so.

The player's reaction should tell you whether it was wrong or not. It should have told John something as well.

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Or do you think that maybe JK should have stopped everything, asked to see a replay and then make a decision on whether to allow the coach to act like an *** or not? Actually, it really doesn't matter. You act like an ***, you get tossed. Earlywine knew it and said as much in his interview.

We have all been in a situation where we instantly question if what we called is actually what happened. In those cases, you have to give the coach some leeway. Not too much, but some.

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Then again, sort of curious why you are so intent on dumping on an umpire for getting rid of a coach who agrees he should have been dumped?

I know I'm anal and obnoxious, what's your excuse?

IDK, maybe it comes from working with him and listening to others who have worked with him often. Maybe it's something I've seen before (see the 2010 Big East Championship game). Something about an umpire that talks about himself in the third person turns me off. If your personal experience with John is different, I understand you defending him.

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by flipper

...Maybe it's something I've seen before (see the 2010 Big East Championship game). Something about an umpire that talks about himself in the third person turns me off....

So, it's personal with you, then. That explains a lot.

[flipper]

Originally Posted by Dakota

So, it's personal with you, then. That explains a lot.

That's right Tom. It's just personal.

Do you know him or have you worked with him? Did you go back and see how he handled the Big East Championship? If so, fine. If not, STFU!

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by flipper

That's right Tom. It's just personal.

Do you know him or have you worked with him? Did you go back and see how he handled the Big East Championship? If so, fine. If not, STFU!

Wow, it really IS personal! Either that or talking about oneself in the 3rd person is #11 on the top ten umpiring no-no's.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by flipper

That's right Tom. It's just personal.

Do you know him or have you worked with him? Did you go back and see how he handled the Big East Championship? If so, fine. If not, STFU!

Inappropriate, bordering on being reported.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by flipper

The player's reaction should tell you whether it was wrong or not. It should have told John something as well.

It should have, but the call was already made and I have little doubt that he believed he made the right call.

We have all been in a situation where we instantly question if what we called is actually what happened. In those cases, you have to give the coach some leeway. Not too much, but some.

Even if I don't question my call, I will give the coach leeway to do his job which is going to be an adversarial position by definition. That doesn't mean s/he is allowed to be more of an ******* than usual. I expect a coach to act in the same professional manner as they would expect of me or any other umpire.

IDK, maybe it comes from working with him and listening to others who have worked with him often. Maybe it's something I've seen before (see the 2010 Big East Championship game). Something about an umpire that talks about himself in the third person turns me off. If your personal experience with John is different, I understand you defending him.

I don't know JK personally, but I'm not defending JK either. I'm defending any umpire who is in that position, even Tony C.

[tcannizzo]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

I don't know JK personally, but I'm not defending JK either. I'm defending any umpire who is in that position, even Tony C.

Just when I thought I was out, they drag me back in. (M. Corleone GodFather III). ==>