Another, 'this doesn't seem right'

[celebur]

Originally Posted by SamG

I get that the K happened with 1 out and first base occupied (2nd out) THEN the play at the plate would have been the third out. My question is whether you can "go back in time" after the pitch being delivered to B5.

Don't confuse this with an appeal play. By rule, the half inning was over when R1 was tagged. The only way to fix this is to negate everything that happened after this third out.