Another ASA quirk

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally posted by Dakota
I understand from a similar discussion on eteamz that the NCAA mechanic is to signal nothing until either the runner touches the base or the fielder tags the runner, and then make the call according to safe or out. (I don't do NCAA so my information is from that thread - fair warning.)

Several of the people in that discussion preferred the NCAA mechanic, since they believed the ASA mechanic of a slight hesitation + safe signal gave the offense a false sense of security - and thereby tips the balance toward the defense.

I would have to say that anyone who buys into that reason either doesn't understand or know the proper mechanic.

The hesitation is to see if either the catcher or runner react in a manner which indicates they are aware that something is amiss. If there is any reaction, the umpire remains silent and allows the play to continue. Of course, depending on the location of the runner, the moment the defender attempts to tag the runner and s/he steps in any direction other than toward the plate, I believe the umpire can rule a basepath violation if appropriate.



Therefore, if there is no reaction by either party, you make the safe call. This play is over and appropriate and properly executed appeals may be honored.