Brain Teaser question

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by MGKBLUE

Under ASA this will depend upon whether the unreported sub, second base, was involved with the double play.

If the double play was completed by the shortstop and first base then R 4.6.8 would not apply. Inthat case I would let the play stand, but I would still disqualify the unreported sub.

From the original post: fires to 2nd. They turn a double play.

Since the base cannot catch the ball , I read this as being F4. Otherwise, I agree, if the offending player is not part of the play, all play stands and no options are given.