What's your call?

[Dakota]

R1 on 2B. B2 hits an infield grounder between 3B and short. Both F5 and F6 are going for the ball. F5 gets there first, gloves the ball. R1 collides with F6, both fall and F5 drops the ball. R1 gets up and proceeds toward 3rd. B2 has rounded 1B and is trying for 2B. F5 picks up the ball and throws to F4 covering 2B. B2 slides in safe at 2B. R1 has rounded 3B and is charging home. Defensive coaches yelling “throw home” from the dugout. F4 throws to F2. The ball and R1 arrive at home together in a cloud of dust. PU sees the tag applied just before R1 slides into home.

What does PU call? (ASA JO Fastpitch)

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally posted by Dakota
R1 on 2B. B2 hits an infield grounder between 3B and short. Both F5 and F6 are going for the ball. F5 gets there first, gloves the ball. R1 collides with F6, both fall and F5 drops the ball. R1 gets up and proceeds toward 3rd. B2 has rounded 1B and is trying for 2B. F5 picks up the ball and throws to F4 covering 2B. B2 slides in safe at 2B. R1 has rounded 3B and is charging home. Defensive coaches yelling “throw home” from the dugout. F4 throws to F2. The ball and R1 arrive at home together in a cloud of dust. PU sees the tag applied just before R1 slides into home.

What does PU call? (ASA JO Fastpitch)

Obstruction F6. As to whether I would call R1 out or safe would probably depend on what I saw happen in the basepath and around 3B. It is a good possibility that I would protect her only to 3B. Of course, if she rounded 3B with a full head of steam, I would have to be thoroughly convinced this would be the normal play, without hesitation from R1, for me not to allow the call at home stand.

Definitley, HTBT.

[Steve M]

I agree with Mike, definitely HTBT. Unless R1 is nonstop going home, the out call will probably stand. Obstruction on F6, R1 protected - but likely only to 3B.

[SamNVa]

Yep, that's the way I see it too. If R1 hesitated at all at 3rd, then the out at home stands. This play points out why it is important for the PU to watch the lead runner all the way from 2nd around 3rd to home.

--SamC

[yugi-oh watcher]

Can anyone recommend a site that offers online training courses in writing as I am looking to upgrade my skills and I don't know where to start. Thanks

[whiskers_ump]

yugi-oh
watcher

You are asking Umpires on where to find a site on learning
about writing skills. Have you read many of our posts???
Just kidding guys...I can't help you yugi-oh watcher, but
if anyone knows, they will give you an answer, I am sure.

glen

[Skahtboi]

Heck...after looking at some of the posts on this website, this may not be the place to learn writing skills, but it is certainly the place to learn verbosity! (Is verbosity a real word?)

Scott

[Gulf Coast Blue]

Verbose.......expressed in or charachterized by the use of many or too many words, wordy......verbosity

Scott.......are you trying to tell me something??

BTW.......as to the umpiring point.........Me too!

Joel

[Dakota]

OK... you guys are missing the real question here.

Why would someone bump a 6 month old thread with a completely off topic response?

[Skahtboi]

Joel:

When are you ever verbose?

[whiskers_ump]

Originally posted by Skahtboi
Joel:

When are you ever verbose?

Nah he is just garrulous.