aplf

[JEL]

alphaump'

Yes specifics can be important in answering here, as well as calling games.

Your original question could be taken to mean Do you allow an appeal after all players (and I mean all) have left the field?

The answer to that would need a clarifier, and that would be Yes, but...this would mean all the defense. Offensive personell could still be on the field, so all is not all.

It can also be taken as, Do you allow an appeal of a bad call? The answer there of course is No. Judgement calls can not be appealed.

It can also be taken to mean, (as I believe was your intent), If a coach asks you to confer with you partner, would you do so, and reverse your call even after all players have left the field? Well thats what I answered. It (the answer) is still there. I even reffered you to the discussion which you later reffered to.

Nomenclature IS important on this board, as well as in the game.

Within the space of a few seconds a player can be a...

Player on the bench,
On deck batter'
Batter,
Batter Runner,
Runner,
Runner who has scored,
Retired Runner,
and maybe a couple more.

With different rules applying to each. Specifics covering a BR can be different from a R, and so forth. Coaches, players and fans don't always understand these differences, and it can cause some confusion.