aplf

[Steve M]

Originally posted by mcrowder
Steve - did you even read the question?

I believe I mentioned what you did on actual appeals.

But he is not really talking about an appeal - he says "a sitch where you would reverse a bad call". A "bad call" is not an "appeal". And YES, you can still fix a bad call if you realize you are in error, so long as play has not continued yet.

MC,
I think we're OK with what each is saying. And look at the time stamps - you & JEL hit enter just a couple minutes before I did. When I'd read the post, nobody had replied. Timing is everything, once again. When Alph specifically said "properly appealed" - I go to an appeal play. Those are like magic words. The answer I gave was correct - for the question I read, but not for what now appears to have been meant.

Now, when asked to check with a partner because a coach thinks I did not see something critical - pulled foot, dropped ball, ... - sure, I'll go just about every time. Unless it's college ball, then I'll go every time.

[Edited by Steve M on Mar 1st, 2006 at 08:48 PM]