If ' ya' had your druthers......

[SC Ump]

Originally posted by booker227
...strong mechanics, or one who had a thorough knowledge of the rules.

So in (a) my partner stands there after the play and I say, "what you got?" He says, "I don't know, I was in position and saw it perfectly, but I don't know what the rule is."

In (b) my partner is still in the A position as the batter runner slides into third and I say, "what you got?" He says, "I didn't see it, but if you'll explain it to me, I quote you the rule number."

Obviously you need some of each. I personally would prefer someone that has good mechanics and can be in great position to make the calls. I would guess 99% of our calls are just "routine" safe and outs.