Overthrow Rule

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally posted by bkbjones


More than one umpire will attest that even with two umpires, this rule of thumb will keep you out of trouble. It is generally accepted practice, and I wish the rule would be changed back to that - especially if the first throw is made by an infielder [including the pitcher (who is making a play on a batted or thrown ball) and the catcher].

Not if you are wrong. And if an umpire quotes that has his ruling, the call now becomes protestable.

Two from the time of the throw is perfect. So good, I believe MLB (and everyone no picked it up after softball started using it.

No question about who is throwing when or where. No question about whether the outfielder was actually in the infield or an infielder throwing from the outfield.

Is it difficult to see? Sometimes, but I don't believe it is that difficult that you change the rule.