situation at first

[outathm]

This is a situation an umpire called me with from this past weekend.

I have looked in the rulebooks I have and can find justification for both safe and out, justifications follow.

I would like to hear what you all think in here.

PLAY:
BR hit ot F6 who bobbles the ball. BR runs past 1B but does not touch the bag. Defense throws to F3 who is touching 1b.

Here are the Justifications:

FED: 8-6-7 OUT Pg 65
8-3-4 OUT Pg 61

PONY: 9-8c OUT Pg 62
9-8g OUT Pg 63

NCAA: 12-8a OUT Pg 155

ASA: 8-3b SAFE Pg 106
8-7g OUT Pg 112