opinions wanted

[Andy]

One of my responsibilities with my HS association is to manage an "incident report" process. I received the following report recently from a HS game and wanted to ask for opinions:

(team name deleted) had a player (in a team jersey
but recreational shorts) with a hard cast on her hand in the dug-out in a pair of thong sandles. She was keeping the book and was an injured player. I pointed this out to (partner) as a safety matter (bare feet) and a possible liability for us if she were to be injured. (partner) talked with the coach and the coach chose to keep the girl in the the dug-out. How far do we take something like this?

My opinion is that this falls in the "looking for boogers" category. Personally, I would not address this unless the player attempted to enter the game or came onto the field to coach at a base. The rulebook is not clear in addressing this particular situation. I think that you could infer going either way and justify it based on the book.

Let's hear what the rest of you have to say....

[Skahtboi]

Originally posted by Andy
My opinion is that this falls in the "looking for boogers" category.

For me, this says it all.

[mcrowder]

I don't believe the footwear of assistant coaches is within my jurisdiction, and as long as this player stayed in the dugout, she's an assistant coach as far as I'm concerned.

[kellerumps]

Like our signature says "We don't look for problems, they find us!!!!"

Sounds like someone was looking for a problem.

[Steve M]

Let's keep it unanimous - went deep, found one big green gooey sticky....

yup, looking for boogers

[whiskers_ump]

Put it in file 13 Andy....Agree with everyone else.

[azbigdawg]

Andy..I hope this was a west side umpire....no respectable east valley umpire would care..... seriously..who cares..even if she comes out between innings in connection with her scorekeep duties..... not an issue

[rhsc]

Well this is a first...everybody agreeing on something.