Appeals

[Skahtboi]

Originally posted by FUBLUE
So, my question is this: Would anyone have made the appeal?

No. I wouldn't have. I would have told him that he cannot question issues of judgement, just as you stated.

Would anyone "walk the coach through" what he could appeal? I mean, according to the coach, he's been umpiring forever and coaching forever (baseball) so he could give us a umpiring clinic. Or would anyone just tell him to be quiet, the play was over, and that was that?

I wouldn't have spent too much time during the game giving him a clinic, though I might would have touched on acceptable questions he can ask to get an umpire to confer with his partner.