Drop Third, Turn and Meet Mr Coach

[Dakota]

Originally posted by BoomerSooner
A simple agreement with the base ump to rule no swing in this situation allows you to appeal the swing and stay with a ball call. Everybody is happy. ...nobody is the wiser.

I know this kind of stuff goes on, complete with secret signals from the PU as to whether the appeal is "real" or not - the "I'm making the appeal, pard, but you need to back my call" signal.

I don't agree with this. If this is brought up at pre-game, I tell my partner that if he asks, I'm going with what I saw, and if I'm at the plate and I ask him, I want what he saw. No "none-the-wiser" stuff.