Check swing mechanic - Plate calls it - Different arm for different batters?

[Tru_in_Blu]

Originally Posted by 3afan

I assume most umpires use their right hand since the mask came off with the left.

The mask is unlikely to be removed when PU calls a check swing a strike. It should come off when PU asks partner for help on the call.

This mechanic (PU calling check swing a strike) is not even mentioned in the USA Umpire Manual.

I picked up this mechanic during a National Umpire School session. I have it backwards to the OP in that for a right-handed batter I will point with the left hand and say "that's a swing" and then give the hammer. For lefties, I point with the right hand followed by the hammer.

And when I worked a National, I actually got dinged for pointing at all. The UIC asked why I was pointing before a strike call. I said I was indicating the batter did not manage to check her swing, the pitch was out of the strike zone (as opposed to a normal called strike), so I did it like I was taught. He wasn't impressed so I lost points as a result.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by Tru_in_Blu

This mechanic (PU calling check swing a strike) is not even mentioned in the USA Umpire Manual.

I believe it is rise to standing position, give hammer signal.

Originally Posted by Tru_in_Blu

And when I worked a National, I actually got dinged for pointing at all.

Yep.

[Tru_in_Blu]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

I believe it is say "strike", rise to standing position, give hammer signal.

I think you have to state that you saw a swing. "Yes! She did!" or "That's a swing."

This lets people (especially coaches) know that while the ball was out of the strike zone, you have a swing, and therefore a strike.

Simply just calling a strike will get you in trouble if a pitch is up around the batter's eyes. If you don't somehow acknowledge it was a swing, coaches will be on you for your crappy strike zone.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by Tru_in_Blu

I think you have to state that you saw a swing. "Yes! She did!" or "That's a swing."

This lets people (especially coaches) know that while the ball was out of the strike zone, you have a swing, and therefore a strike.

Simply just calling a strike will get you in trouble if a pitch is up around the batter's eyes. If you don't somehow acknowledge it was a swing, coaches will be on you for your crappy strike zone.

I corrected mt post to not say "strike", just signal.