Quote:
Originally posted by AndrewMcCarthy
Quote:
Originally posted by Theisey
That case play isn't anywhere like this one. That case book play the ball is muffed up into the air.. This play talks about a catch/BANG play. That is KCI.
|
Not the way I read it... R does not make a clean catch and is immediately hit by K1. The ball is recovered by K2.
Sounds like the same play to me- K gave him the opportunity to make the catch and he didn't catch it. Legal play.
To me, "does not make a clean catch" = bobble = muff into air.
However, if he bobbles then catches and then is hit by K, we have a foul- R has protection and the ball is dead when R makes the catch (secures possession).
|
### After you have read the clarification posted by "citfirst", do you still believe his play is not KCI?
Maybe some will not flag it, but I'll not let that go without a flag.
Thu Sep 04, 2003, 08:12pm
Hybrid Mode
