Alabama/Auburn

[OKREF]

4:01 in second quarter.

Run initially called TD, replay reversed it. Sure looked liked the ball crossed the goal line as his hand touched the ground out of bounds.

[stiffler3492]

Originally Posted by OKREF

4:01 in second quarter.

Run initially called TD, replay reversed it. Sure looked liked the ball crossed the goal line as his hand touched the ground out of bounds.

Agreed, They took it frame by frame and it sure looked like the right call on the field.

[InsideTheStripe]

Originally Posted by stiffler3492

Agreed, They took it frame by frame and it sure looked like the right call on the field.

Didn't care for that reversal. Or the reversal at 1:40.

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by InsideTheStripe

Didn't care for that reversal. Or the reversal at 1:40.

Agree. I thought the replay official missed both.

[PAUmpire]

On the final play. Anyone else see that player in the back field waving his hand back and forth? Could that have been considered a fair catch signal? while the ball was in flight.


I wouldnt have called just curious.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HqIBNX0CXDc

[Rich]

Originally Posted by PAUmpire

On the final play. Anyone else see that player in the back field waving his hand back and forth? Could that have been considered a fair catch signal? while the ball was in flight.


I wouldnt have called just curious.

No. Not unless common sense took an inopportune vacation.

[HLin NC]

He was waving before the snap. Exhorting the crowd.

[asdf]

How about the sideline not covered on the return?

The L is stuck inside when he pinches in after the kick. The F is under the upright and has no chance to get to the sideline. While Davis does not go out of bounds, that sideline was challenged and not covered until the L recovers from the hash (you see him weaving between players) and gets there after Davis passes him and cuts it back inside....

[Rich]

Originally Posted by asdf

How about the sideline not covered on the return?

The L is stuck inside when he pinches in after the kick. The F is under the upright and has no chance to get to the sideline. While Davis does not go out of bounds, that sideline was challenged and not covered until the L recovers from the hash (you see him weaving between players) and gets there after Davis passes him and cuts it back inside....

The L got sucked in. Thankfully, replay would've been there if the runner had stepped out of bounds.