NFHS question

[CT1]

Originally Posted by JasonLJ

I still had it as roughing, same as the WH.

Not trying to be ugly, but why were you looking at the QB?

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by CT1

Not trying to be ugly, but why were you looking at the QB?

I did not take this has him actually looking at the QB or passer. I took this has him explaining why he would go with RTP. As this appears to have been a coach-official conference. And depending on the play, he would be looking at the QB rolling to his side and might notice him getting hit and might even notice a tipped ball immediately as well.

Peace

[JasonLJ]

Originally Posted by CT1

Not trying to be ugly, but why were you looking at the QB?

I wasn't. I actually was umpiring this game. The WH asked if the ball was tipped, I told him it was. I was just agreeing that if he had roughing, then the call should stand regardless of the tipped ball.

[CT1]

Originally Posted by JasonLJ

I wasn't. I actually was umpiring this game. The WH asked if the ball was tipped, I told him it was. I was just agreeing that if he had roughing, then the call should stand regardless of the tipped ball.

OK, sorry. I took your post to mean that you *also* thought the hit on the passer was RTP.