Flag thrown for TD Celebration

[Raymond]

They're playing Archbishop Murphy in their next game, might be a lot of flags.

[InsideTheStripe]

Originally Posted by TXMike

I suspect the covering official will say the flag was thrown for the player drawing attentoion to himself.

It appears to me the covering official was trying to draw attention to himself.

[chseagle]

Here's the response from the WIAA Executive Director, Mike Colbrese:

"WIAA Statement Regarding 2A Semifinal Penalty
12/2/2010

Reports of a ‘high school football player penalized for praying’ in the end zone following a touchdown have greatly exaggerated an official’s call and taken it out of context. During last Monday’s 2A state semifinal game, a player dropped to one knee and pointed skyward following a touchdown.

Based on national playing rule (NFHS 9-5.C) the referee considered the gesture ‘an excessive or prolonged act during which the player drew attention to himself’. That was the basis of the penalty with no inference to religion or a player’s right to offer a personal reflection of thanks for performing well.

While the official’s judgment was based on a national federation rule, the WIAA will continue to work with the Washington Officials Association to ensure consistent, enforcement and interpretations of playing rules for future contests.

--Mike Colbrese, WIAA Executive Director"

[ottobabble]

Originally Posted by InsideTheStripe

It appears to me the covering official was trying to draw attention to himself.

I thought so too!
Maybe he learned something from all this.

[umpirebob71]

Originally Posted by chseagle

Here's the response from the WIAA Executive Director, Mike Colbrese:

"WIAA Statement Regarding 2A Semifinal Penalty
12/2/2010

Reports of a ‘high school football player penalized for praying’ in the end zone following a touchdown have greatly exaggerated an official’s call and taken it out of context. During last Monday’s 2A state semifinal game, a player dropped to one knee and pointed skyward following a touchdown.

Based on national playing rule (NFHS 9-5.C) the referee considered the gesture ‘an excessive or prolonged act during which the player drew attention to himself’. That was the basis of the penalty with no inference to religion or a player’s right to offer a personal reflection of thanks for performing well.

While the official’s judgment was based on a national federation rule, the WIAA will continue to work with the Washington Officials Association to ensure consistent, enforcement and interpretations of playing rules for future contests.

--Mike Colbrese, WIAA Executive Director"

That is, of course, the rule. What the rulebook does not give you, is the common sense to apply the rule judisciously. That act was neither "excessive" or "prolonged." Spin it all you like, Mr. Colbrese. That official overreacted to a simple benign gesture.

[asdf]

Imagine that chaos that would have been created if pink whistles were involved.

[parepat]

Along the same lines. In the Ohio State - Michigan game an OSU player was flagged for making an "O" symbol after scoring. Has anyone been flagged from Texas for making the "Hookem Horns" symbol?