Mike Carey

[secondregionbug]

Great job!

[Dakota]

But leaving that one second on the clock was silly. A slow finger on the stopwatch would have been much better than requiring the final knee.

[Ed Hickland]

In reviewing game video there appeared to be two seconds on the clock at the end of the fourth down play.

To have ended the game with time remaining would not have fit the character of Mike Carey. Take a look at this http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d80678c74 then think about it.

I have to say Mike Carey embodies the character and precision that each of us should carry every time we step on the field.

[bigjohn]

No reason to make them take a knee!

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by bigjohn

No reason to make them take a knee!

You cannot just arbitrarily end the game on a second on the clock. People would have complained there was a conspiracy if they did not play that last second.

Peace

[MNBlue]

Can you say, "Joe Pisarcik"?

[cmathews]

Originally Posted by bigjohn

No reason to make them take a knee!

ok at what point do we go ahead and quit letting the game end with time on the clock...2, 4 8 25 seconds?? I somewhat agree that if the pats just wanted to go in that it could be over, however why deprive the Giants of the feeling of getting to take a knee, with the knowledge that they have just won the super bowl...

[Blue37]

Does the NFL have an equivalent to the NFHS rule?

Rule 3 Periods, Time Factors and Substitutions
SECTION 1 LENGTH OF PERIODS
ART. 3 A period or periods may be shortened in any emergency by agreement of the opposing coaches and the referee. By mutual agreement of the opposing coaches and the referee, any remaining period may be shortened at any time or the game terminated.

In a Fed game, if I see the coaches heading for mid-field to shake hands, I accept that as their agreement to terminate the game. My agreement is demonstrated by leaving the field.

[Forksref]

This is the Super Bowl, not the intramural semi-finals. Do it RIGHT!

And, since I didn't hardly notice the crew, they must have done a good job.

[HossHumard]

I agree, I think the crew did a real nice job as I barely noticed them as well. For once, I thought the Super Bowl was actually, well, a super (entertaining) game!

Once question for my 'murrican brothers about the "Too Many Men" (Illegal Sub.) though.

In Canadian Amateur in a similar situation where the player is high tailing it to his bench and he gets off close to (before) the snap, as long as he did not participate in the play, there's no call. At CFL I believe the situation gets covered by the penalty for having 13 guys (1 too many) in the huddle. Do you guys really nail teams if they're within a half second of a guy touching his sidelines? Is it the same with US Amateur as it is with the NFL? How on earth do you make that call if so?

Thx

[Bob M.]

Originally Posted by HossHumard

...Once question for my 'murrican brothers about the "Too Many Men" (Illegal Sub.) though.

In Canadian Amateur in a similar situation where the player is high tailing it to his bench and he gets off close to (before) the snap, as long as he did not participate in the play, there's no call. At CFL I believe the situation gets covered by the penalty for having 13 guys (1 too many) in the huddle. Do you guys really nail teams if they're within a half second of a guy touching his sidelines? Is it the same with US Amateur as it is with the NFL? How on earth do you make that call if so?

Thx

REPLY: In Federation and NCAA ball the rules are just as strict as they are in the NFL--if the player running to the sideline doesn't get off before the snap, technically it's a foul for illegal substitution. However, in practical application, most officials handle it the same way you suggest: If the guy is close enough to the sideline to not make a difference, most officials will let it go ("no harm, no foul"). But in the NFL, since the number of players on the field at the snap is a reviewable situation, they have to call it strictly, the same way they would for a runner being inbounds or out-of-bounds on a tightrope down the sideline. They really have no choice in the NFL. It's got to be called by the book.

[BigGref]

I agree with the common interpretation/enforcement here. Unless the player is still in the middle of the field and within a step or two I usually let it go. I think that this situation is just that case, the player was only a step and half away. They should not be able to review situations like this, leave to official's discretion. And I'm a colts fan and they do it all the time.

Originally Posted by HossHumard

Once question for my 'murrican brothers about the "Too Many Men" (Illegal Sub.) though.
... Do you guys really nail teams if they're within a half second of a guy touching his sidelines? Is it the same with US Amateur as it is with the NFL? How on earth do you make that call if so?

Thx

[Rich]

Maybe I'm the contrarian here, but I tell my wings to make sure the guy gets off or they should flag it.

[Bob M.]

Originally Posted by BigGref

....They should not be able to review situations like this, leave to official's discretion. And I'm a colts fan and they do it all the time.

REPLY: At one time, if I'm not mistaken, it was not reviewable. Then there was a high-profile mistake (allegedly) where Bill Cowher was running off the field at halftime livid, showing the referee one of those Polaroid shots they take that had their opponent (again, allegedly) with twelve guys on the field. After that, I believe, they made it a reviewable situation.

[Ed Hickland]

Originally Posted by Blue37

Does the NFL have an equivalent to the NFHS rule?

Rule 3 Periods, Time Factors and Substitutions
SECTION 1 LENGTH OF PERIODS
ART. 3 A period or periods may be shortened in any emergency by agreement of the opposing coaches and the referee. By mutual agreement of the opposing coaches and the referee, any remaining period may be shortened at any time or the game terminated.

In a Fed game, if I see the coaches heading for mid-field to shake hands, I accept that as their agreement to terminate the game. My agreement is demonstrated by leaving the field.

I heard the the FOX announcers say the NFL wanted the last second played. Therefore, it was not Mike Carey's choice.

Remember, the Cleveland beer tossing incident and the disputed field goal this season again with Cleveland. Both those incidents even though the outcome was not in doubt, the league made them play it out. I know for a fact in the beer tossing incident it was NFL control in New York that dictated the game be completed.