A question of Ethics?

[Suudy]

Originally posted by mcrowder
Suudy, I'm not sure what the best adjective is for me to use in this situation to differentiate from your adjective of "technically" correct. He's not just technically correct, he's completely correct, and completely within his rights to be furious. In essence, you had an inadvertent whistle, and needed to handle it that way.

Fair enough. He was completely correct. I guess my feeling at the time (and at the time of writing) was that it's not an uncommon process (at least in games I've done) for A to just "touch" the ball dead. You are correct in that we should wait until it is possessed, or at rest.