Chiefs vs Steelers--2 pt try

[Kansas Ref]

There was a holding call made against our KC left tackle on an edge rusher on Pitt in last SUnday Playoff Game. The result of the call was that it disallowed our successful 2 pt try that would've tied the game. Many fans are saying that the such call should have been ignored because the Pitt player was falling down anyhow. Even a HS football ref told me that he would've passed on the call.
Am I missing something here? Do NFL officials call games tighter than HS level refs? Would it have been reasonable to pass on that call? Or was that call really a call that a normal ref would've made--despite the gravity of the situation?

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Kansas Ref

There was a holding call made against our KC left tackle on an edge rusher on Pitt in last SUnday Playoff Game. The result of the call was that it disallowed our successful 2 pt try that would've tied the game. Many fans are saying that the such call should have been ignored because the Pitt player was falling down anyhow. Even a HS football ref told me that he would've passed on the call.
Am I missing something here? Do NFL officials call games tighter than HS level refs? Would it have been reasonable to pass on that call? Or was that call really a call that a normal ref would've made--despite the gravity of the situation?

Our?

I would not have passed and I'm also a HS ref. So, are we even now?

Whether I call a hold on that play has nothing to do with the situation. Two points is two points.

[Mbilica]

That was a hook and restrict that turned into a takedown. The defender wouldn't fall down if he hadn't been dragged down...

Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk

[WhistlesAndStripes]

Originally Posted by Kansas Ref

There was a holding call made against our KC left tackle on an edge rusher on Pitt in last SUnday Playoff Game. The result of the call was that it disallowed our successful 2 pt try that would've tied the game. Many fans are saying that the such call should have been ignored because the Pitt player was falling down anyhow. Even a HS football ref told me that he would've passed on the call.
Am I missing something here? Do NFL officials call games tighter than HS level refs? Would it have been reasonable to pass on that call? Or was that call really a call that a normal ref would've made--despite the gravity of the situation?

I'm a former HS Football official, and that was as clear a hold as you can find. Wipe away your tears, congratulate the Steelers, and better luck next year.

[Rich]

Wonder if the HS FB ref referenced in the first post was a Chiefs fan, too.

[MD Longhorn]

I think we should thank that lineman for video we can use to show a perfect example of a hold in our clinics next season.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Kansas Ref

Even a HS football ref told me that he would've passed on the call. Am I missing something here?

Well I am a HS Referee and I would have called that a hold. And would have called that if it was a college game. Maybe the guys you asked were not worth a crap at that level?

Originally Posted by Kansas Ref

Do NFL officials call games tighter than HS level refs? Would it have been reasonable to pass on that call? Or was that call really a call that a normal ref would've made--despite the gravity of the situation?

No, usually the NFL requires more takedowns to get a hold call. HS officials in my experience have a simple jersey pull even if for a moment and call a foul. Yes the call was warranted and warranted at all levels I work and I do not work the NFL. Who cares about the situation as well. If you prevent the defender from making a play, that is the point of attack.

Peace

[Adam]

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn

I think we should thank that lineman for video we can use to show a perfect example of a hold in our clinics next season.

This

[WhistlesAndStripes]

Well, here's a pretty blunt statement by the NFL about what they thought of the call:

SUPER BOWL LI OFFICIATING CREW ANNOUNCED

Kelce, from the Chefs, will love that!!

[Kansas Ref]

Well I guess that settles it.

[Texas Aggie]

He had already been put in there, though I guess its possible he could have been removed had he screwed something up badly.

My problem with the call is that it is initiated by the defender's arm coming up and locking the offensive player's arm into that position. Could the offensive player have released had he wanted to?