Two videos

[Robert Goodman]

Originally Posted by Reffing Rev.

Our crew worked an 8-man playoff game yesterday. V coach sent me these two plays.

https://youtu.be/4zybWNzmlHI

False Start or Legal Motion and Encroachment? H had encroachment, R (me) had a false start. I went with the FST. Coach disagrees.

In Fed rules, I see encroachment by B. In NCAA, also an encroachment, killing the ball, because the DL's move into the neutral zone drew the snapper's flinch, which I take to be a "spontaneous reaction charge".

#14's action is a legal shift.

https://youtu.be/9o7qnxCiDYE

Illegal forward handoff or legal play? I believe it is illegal, but I missed it on the field.

Illegal [forward] handing of the ball in both Fed & NCAA. The rules in both are written crappily in such a way as to make it arguably impossible ever to call, but by their spirit it's a forward handoff under conditions where the receiver of it is ineligible to take possession.