Question from Fanboy site

[jTheUmp]

Originally Posted by Adam

2. Fans who spout rule terminology are wasting their time. Either the official already knows the rules and their assistance is not required, or the official doesn't know the rules and their help isn't going to actually, well, help.

I might be in the minority on this, but when I was a newbie and hadn't yet developed me keen ability to ignore fans, occasionally a "fan spouting rule terminology" would give me a "hey, maybe I have the rule wrong" reaction. I wouldn't let it change my actions in the current game, of course, but it would give me cause to dig into the rule book later in the evening. And occasionally I'd learn something, although usually I'd learn that the fan was an idiot.

An example: in my first year, I had one game where I called 4 or 5 violations for a ball hitting the top of the backboard (not going over, just hitting the top). After the 3rd one, I overheard a fan comment about "that's wrong, it's a dead ball only when it hits a backboard support"... In my sojurn into the rules later that evening, I found out that the fan was partially right, and I was wrong.

[egj13]

I read the OP in the sense that the guy is asking if we kick calls because we are peeved at the "abuse" we are taking? Asking if we hold grudges?

I can say for myself that I have several gyms that I absolutely abhor going too...fans that say things that would make most of you blush. But at the same time I go in with a fresh slate each game. I was at the worst of them the other night and the V coach said something about getting homered...I said "coach, if you had any idea the number of times I have been police escorted out of this gym you would know this is the last place you will be homered at..." he chuckled because he probably thought I was joking!

Bottom line is, there are some that probably do hold it against teams but the majority of us just try and call our best game each time.

[bainsey]

Originally Posted by egj13

I read the OP in the sense that the guy is asking if we kick calls because we are peeved at the "abuse" we are taking? Asking if we hold grudges?

Actually, quite the contrary. The question is whether even the most civil of objections from the stands leads to kicked calls.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by bainsey

Actually, quite the contrary. The question is whether even the most civil of objections from the stands leads to kicked calls.

I took it as asking whether a civil objection from the stands could in fact reduce kicked calls.

And I contend that the only possible in-game impacts of even the most civil objections are either neutral or negative (I don't mean by grudge, I mean because an official is either distracted or flustered.)

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by jTheUmp

..... occasionally a "fan spouting rule terminology" would give me a "hey, maybe I have the rule wrong" reaction. I wouldn't let it change my actions in the current game, of course......

Why not? Anybody can make a mistake. If you realize the mistake in time to correct it, what difference does it make where the information came from.


Example: You're about to shoot free throws, when a voice from the stands yells, "That was a team control foul, you morons!" Oops, he's right. We are morons. White team OOB.