The Official Forum - Tripping, Or Being Tripped ???

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)

- - Tripping, Or Being Tripped ??? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/99141-tripping-being-tripped.html)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Camron Rust (Post 952081)

They remove things from the case book, not to change them, but to make space for new interpretations in other areas. They have to remove something when adding something so they don't have to keep adding pages and printing costs. When they want to change a ruling, they don't silently remove it, they replace it with one or more new ones that express the new ruling.

The player lying on the floor is in a legal position (in NFHS only). A stationary player owns their space from head to toe regardless if their orientation is vertical or horizontal .

Tell me where you get this from. I've pointed out that the screening rule specifically says a player has to have a STANCE and stay inside the vertical plane. Legal Guarding says vertical plane. A player gets a spot on the floor. Lying down takes up multiple spots. A player in your game can lay down to set a screen. defense now has to avoid a six foot space instead of another player vertical in his plane. double or triple screen with only one player....

Camron is correct.

There is a casebook situation that specifically addresses this, and that interpretation remains in effect until it it specifically changed, which NFHS has not done.

The screening rule is irrelevant in the situation being discussed.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TimTaylor (Post 952100)

The screening rue is irrelevant in the situation being discussed.

As is any reference to LGP irrelevant, with player on floor not moving after obtaining his position on the floor legally. He may or may not have LGP but that is not germane to making the proper call on this play.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigCat (Post 952085)

His body doesn't get any bigger. Go ahead and try to play defense on the floor...pretty hard to block a pass or shot from there.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigCat (Post 952085)

A player in your game can lay down to set a screen. defense now has to avoid a six foot space instead of another player vertical in his plane. double or triple screen with only one player....

If a player does it on purpose, there are other case plays to deal with that and it isn't going to be a common foul.