Final piece of the puzzle

[asdf]

Originally Posted by just another ref

In her answer about the blarge play NFHS rulebook editor Theresia Wynns ultimately stated one should check with ones own state to see how this play should be administered.

So I did.

We had a meeting tonight to discuss association business. In attendance was Keith Alexander, LHSAA Supervisor of Officials. I asked him about the play.

"According to some in our discussion group, if the two officials give conflicting preliminary signals, they must report both fouls. True?"

He answered quickly, without hesitation. He did not specifically say that he was familiar with this particular case play, but I got the impression that he was. His answer: "No, only if neither will yield to the other." And he added pointedly, "And it should never come to that."

I agreed.

Why didn't you specifically tell him that the Case Book tells us that it is a double foul?

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by asdf

Why didn't you specifically tell him that the Case Book tells us that it is a double foul?

Everybody knows that the case is about a double foul. The question is whether signals are the key to the case. The answer is no.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by just another ref

Everybody knows that the case is about a double foul. The question is whether signals are the key to the case. The answer is no.

The answer is "no" for Louisiana. That's not the answer in Virginia.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

The answer is "no" for Louisiana and according to the NFHS editor. That's not the answer in Virginia.

[Nevadaref]

Is Louisiana the state which still uses some bizarre three-person mechanic?

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Is Louisiana the state which still uses some bizarre three-person mechanic?

And this is relevant in this thread how?

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by just another ref

And this is relevant in this thread how?

It speaks to the thinking and mindset of Mr. Alexander.
So please tell us about 3-person mechanics in your state. How do they differ from NFHS mechanics?