The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Injury During Rebound Scrum (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/97150-injury-during-rebound-scrum.html)

Adam Thu Jan 30, 2014 01:29pm

Injury During Rebound Scrum
 
Shot goes up, and during rebounding action, A1 goes down with an injury on one side of the lane. By this time, the rebounding scrum is on the other side of the paint (player is safely alone).

Do you:

1. Blow the whistle immediately and go to the arrow?
2. Wait to see who gets the ball and decide at that time?

MD Longhorn Thu Jan 30, 2014 01:37pm

A scrum is a scrum --- you don't know what direction that's going after the next time the ball gets redirected. Kill it if it's not immediately apparent that this kid is getting up.

bob jenkins Thu Jan 30, 2014 01:41pm

HTBT, but I lean toward waiting.

BryanV21 Thu Jan 30, 2014 01:45pm

If there's a chance the player is hurt, or could get hurt, I'm killing it. Their safety is #1. If a coach doesn't understand that then he's the problem... not me.

JRutledge Thu Jan 30, 2014 01:51pm

I am with Bob. Unless a player is squirting blood, I think we can wait a second or two.

Peace

Rich Thu Jan 30, 2014 02:25pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 920548)
htbt, but i lean toward waiting.

+1

BatteryPowered Thu Jan 30, 2014 02:27pm

I am leaning toward killing it out of an abundance of caution. I guess the question would be who would get the ball if it is a scrum. I don't have books with me (and cannot remember if it is even addressed), but I am thinking we go to the arrow if my partner(s) cannot say for certain who had the ball.

BryanV21 Thu Jan 30, 2014 02:35pm

I should have also added that it depends on the level. The lower the level, the better chance I kill it right away. By the time I get to the Varsity level or higher, then I'm going to wait a second or so... as long as the player on the ground isn't in immediate danger.

stick Thu Jan 30, 2014 05:20pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BryanV21 (Post 920580)
I should have also added that it depends on the level. The lower the level, the better chance I kill it right away. By the time I get to the Varsity level or higher, then I'm going to wait a second or so... as long as the player on the ground isn't in immediate danger.

Had a play during a girls CYO game a couple years ago. A1 is dribbling and A2 comes over to set a pick. A2 stumbles and accidently collides with A1, both go down. The ball pops out, B1 grabs it, goes down the court for an uncontested layup. My partner thens kill the play (I followed B1 down the court), call the coach out to tend to his injured girls who did get up but were a bit woozy. Team A's coach goes nuts on us for not stopping the play after the collision happened.
1) Should we have stopped the play at the point of the collision?
2) Or did we do the right thing?

Adam Thu Jan 30, 2014 05:23pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by stick (Post 920665)
Had a play during a girls CYO game a couple years ago. A1 is dribbling and A2 comes over to set a pick. A2 stumbles and accidently collides with A1, both go down. The ball pops out, B1 grabs it, goes down the court for an uncontested layup. My partner thens kill the play (I followed B1 down the court), call the coach out to tend to his injured girls who did get up but were a bit woozy. Team A's coach goes nuts on us for not stopping the play after the collision happened.
1) Should we have stopped the play at the point of the collision?
2) Or did we do the right thing?

That's what I would have done.
Then, I would have reminded the coach that he's been allowed on the court to tend to his players. He doesn't get to go nuts on you.

Toren Thu Jan 30, 2014 06:34pm

I had a similar play in a varsity contest two weeks ago.

Player A1 pulls up for a jumper and clearly his leg buckles and he shoots a dart at the rim. It bounces and the defense secures and fast breaks. Player A1 is holding his leg on the court.

I am the new lead and I take off with the fast break. Team B is about to score when I hear a crack of the whistle. Well my new T, cracked his whistle because the player was down on the ground and coach B had clearly influenced my partner enough to get him to crack.

Team A coach is yelling, and in my opinion rightly so, because we just stopped his advantage. I told the T, at the next opportunity, we don't stop play on a fast break with the other team has the advantage.

If they back out or score, then we can stop play. Except if it's a life and death or we see squirting blood.

Turns out the kid just had a cramp and he was up and walking within minutes.

BryanV21 Thu Jan 30, 2014 09:23pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by stick (Post 920665)
Had a play during a girls CYO game a couple years ago. A1 is dribbling and A2 comes over to set a pick. A2 stumbles and accidently collides with A1, both go down. The ball pops out, B1 grabs it, goes down the court for an uncontested layup. My partner thens kill the play (I followed B1 down the court), call the coach out to tend to his injured girls who did get up but were a bit woozy. Team A's coach goes nuts on us for not stopping the play after the collision happened.
1) Should we have stopped the play at the point of the collision?
2) Or did we do the right thing?

I guess it's not so cut and dry. I mean... did the girls bash their heads together? Did they hit their heads on the floor when they fell? Or did they just run into each other and fall down? If they simply ran into each other, and there didn't appear to be any injury, then by all means let the play go and re-examine things after the basket.

I would never fault another official for killing play because he/she thought somebody was hurt/injured. Especially in a rec contest.

AremRed Thu Jan 30, 2014 09:50pm

Had a girls game last week. Girl drives along the endline from C opposite towards me at Lead tableside. She passes the ball into into the lane, and immediately trips over another girls feet (incidental). She falls and hits the floor face-first. I've never seen anything like it, her head bounced off the floor like a bouncy-ball. The ball was loose in the middle of the lane, being batted around by s few girls.

I blew it dead immediately. Girl was fine, walked off almost right away. Resumed at arrow. As others have said, you gotta have a feel for it.

Zoochy Fri Jan 31, 2014 12:19pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by AremRed (Post 920686)
Had a girls game last week. Girl drives along the endline from C opposite towards me at Lead tableside. She passes the ball into into the lane, and immediately trips over another girls feet (incidental). She falls and hits the floor face-first. I've never seen anything like it, her head bounced off the floor like a bouncy-ball. The ball was loose in the middle of the lane, being batted around by s few girls.

I blew it dead immediately. Girl was fine, walked off almost right away. Resumed at arrow. As others have said, you gotta have a feel for it.

Good job killing the play when the potential injured player is still in the area of the loose ball.
Why AP arrow? Even though the ball is loose, the team did not lose Team Control. Give the ball back to the Offensive team at the nearest location of the ball.

JRutledge Fri Jan 31, 2014 12:25pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zoochy (Post 920756)
Good job killing the play when the potential injured player is still in the area of the loose ball.
Why AP arrow? Even though the ball is loose, the team did not lose Team Control. Give the ball back to the Offensive team at the nearest location of the ball.

Not sure that is how the rule would reads.

Peace


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:35am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1