Putting hands on official? (Video added)
Is it an automatic dq if a player puts hsi(or her) hands on an official. Late in the 1st half of the Illinois 2A boys title game a player did so and was subsequently dq'ed. However that was his 2nd T as he had just received a T for the same play so he could have been dq'ed for that. If not for the 1st T is that an automatic DQ(or ejection as called on the TV broadcast)
|
Not necessarily automatic, but very likely.
|
Quote:
|
It is pretty automatic. I saw the play too and it was a good call. I can see this play being used as an example in future videos in our state.
Peace |
Quote:
|
APG, Jet - anyone able to post this one for those of us who didn't see it?
|
Quote:
If I can get copy of the play, I will post it. But I certainly feel it was warranted and would have been warranted if it was the first T. Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
South Holland (Seton Academy) vs Harrisburg?
If that's the game, I might be able to get a clip of the play later. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/dsMAUlT5v-o" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
|
Adios son, enjoy the game from the bench.
|
Either way on this one he was done, it was his 2nd T.
Touching an official may or may not be a flagrant T, however. If it is hostile, FF. If it is chummy (puts their arm across your shoulder to ask a question), probably nothing. |
Statement from the IHSA on tonights 2A title game
IHSA Statement on Class 2A Boys Basketball State Championship Game > IHSA |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I have a rather good source there was a lot going on in the arena. I heard there were some words from the stands and other places that were inappropriate.
Peace |
My source is a media source. I defer to those who have more info. Here is where I got a good amount of my info as well as this one from Peoria.
IHSA Class 2A boys basketball state final: Seton leaves upset after upset loss to Harrisburg during which Mark Weeks was ejected - chicagotribune.com http://www.pjstar.com/sports/sportsc...early-and-late |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
That said, the 2 technical fouls called in the video above seemed to be right on the money and showed an official who reacted properly to a situation. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
My guess is the guy who wrote the column went overboard with how the game was handled but we can all watch for ourselves. I definitely don't like the fact he not only mentioned the officials' names but the towns in which they live. |
Quote:
|
Preface-I'm an official from the Peoria area and had no rooting interest in the game other than a fan of basketball.
I was at this game and about 40 feet from where the T's were called. #4 that got booted probably should have been T'd earlier in the game. With a ringside seat I could see him trash talking from the tip-off. I am going to say this while biting my tongue because as we all know you hate to judge another official and I very rarely do, but these guys let the game get to the point they had these technicals. They had no control over this game out of the shoot. Thus it escalated into what it did. You had kids whacking each other, talking trash and acting like fools with nothing happening from the officials. Kids off ball were beating the hell out of each other and nothing. Somebody would get killed on one end of the floor in a giant crash with nothing and then a touch foul at the other end. It was odd to watch. I counted 6 crashes at the basket with bodies everywhere and nothing. In their defense there was one official who tried to clean it up, but he was not enough. The other two unfortunately laid an egg. It was hard to watch. I felt bad for them to make it to the pinnacle in a championship game and then have a train wreck. Someone mentioned the fans. I was very near the Harrisburg fans and they were brutal. If it would have been in a high school gym several of them would have been ejected. Some of the stuff they were saying was embarrassing to say the least. With all that said as usual the losing team still easily could have won if they had just hit their free throws. If they shoot 70% from the line they win anyway. It wasn't a great way for the fans, players, coaches or the officials to end their season. |
Quote:
Take a look at Blue #11 on the sideline view right after he's called for the foul. He gives White #4 a little shove in the back. That's what led to White #4's first T for saying something to Blue #11. When the T is called White #4 looks to the official and tries to show him what Blue #11 did...again, not the best move on his part. When I first watched the play the thing that jumped out at me was there wasn't really any anger on White #4's face as he approached/made contact with the official. I know, we're not psychologists out there but that didn't make sense to me if he was truly angry about the call. |
JetMetFan-
You are correct on all counts. But several times leading up to this point in the game #4 white was trash talking and was angrily gesturing and talking to the officials. They didn't take care of it early, so it escalated into what it did. |
Regarding the Comments in this story
For an interesting(to say the least) perspective from some people read the comments from the Chicago Tribune Story
http://www.chicagotribune.com/sports...,1172517.story |
Quote:
|
Hot Town, Summer InThe City ...
Quote:
The suburban games, and rural games, are basketball, but they're a very different type of basketball. Not better. Not worse. Just different. I'm fortunate that I can officiate all different kinds of basketball here in my little corner of Connecticut, city, suburban, and rural, and I enjoy officiating all three types. I would probably have a problem if I only officiated city games and then had to do a game in a rural community. Contact that kids can play through in the city, they can't play through in the country. City games seem to move at a faster pace. The coaching is different. The players are different. The parents, and other fans, are different. And each group has a different expectation about how the game will officiated. It's the same game, but it's different, and very hard to explain, without being condescending to a particular group, or thought of as a racist, or a country-phile, or a city-phile. |
Quote:
At any rate, White #4 had two common fouls against him. Both were in the 2nd and he never reacted to the official. After the 2nd foul (a hand check), Blue #11 gave him a shove and the two may have had words. One thing I will say about that play is the calling official should have blown his whistle a few seconds earlier when White #4 had a locked arm against Blue #11's torso. If he gets that, the second hand check - and possibly Blue #11's reaction - don't happen. I'm not trying to be the kid's attorney but the video doesn't support saying he was "trash talking and...angrily gesturing and talking to the officials." Obviously I wasn't there so maybe stuff happened off camera but he sure didn't do anything out of the ordinary in front of the bright lights. Quote:
Did he do it from the grassy knoll, too? |
Quote:
Billy's post upthread is spot on. It's a different style of play and how contact is called is one of the big factors. Another factor is how vigilant you have to be when it comes to things like trash talking and unsportsmanlike behaviors. Play routinely above the rim is another factor. |
Quote:
Great post...my guess is that one would just have to work both city and rural leagues to truly understand the differences in both. I vividly remember the first city league game I worked and (my guess is that) I seemed completely overwhelmed the first few minuets getting adjusted to the speed and athleticism the city kids had. You just simply can't officiate the two types of games the same. You see some of the plays that the city kids do and they are things that no rural kid that I've ever seen would be able to accomplish. |
Typically, it seems to me the difference is more about the size of the school than the geographic location of the school. I work a lot of big school city ball, small school city ball, and rural ball (some rural schools are actually closer to me than some city schools within the local city limits), and school size is the biggest difference. Bigger schools have bigger talent pools from which to draw players, so the players are faster, stronger, taller, and play higher.
The key is to be flexible enough to recognize when contact presents an advantage and when it doesn't. |
just watched the first half....this crew wasn't ready for this game. Several plays/actions took place and the crew didn't know what to do/how to handle.....
regardless, players/coaches CAN'T let their emotions cause them to react as poorly as players/coaches did on both sides..... |
Billy Mac's post is spot on.....
That said, having a city school play a downstate rural school, I would have liked to seen a mix of officials that fit Billy's description who would have been able to adapt to any style game, it didn't appear to be the case here. Second T was warranted, easy one. First one on kid, I dunno. I have know idea what he said, if he had been warned previously, but from tape only I would've passed, especially noting that #11 pushed him ever so slightly in back. To step in and tell him/them to knock it off seemed like the better course. Again from tape only, it didn't seem like much. Earlier in game there was a situation with Seton coach where official should have gotten away from him after a warning regarding coach's box, Seton coach is then talking to official and is at most two feet out of box and official is pointing him to get back, you have to see it, it just doesn't look good. Having watched most of game, it was ugly and a tough game to officiate. |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
Another thing that struck me: the body language of the crew during some of the situations. Example: the look on the official's face when he called the T on Blue #55. Also, the look on the officials' faces when they addressed the coaches. Again, I wasn't there and I have no idea what was said but one thing discussed in other threads is trying to keep emotion out of things when making calls. I'm planning to post some plays from the 1st half when I get home from work later this morning. As always, I'm not doing it to ride the officials. We've all been there at some point. It's more to show how a couple of calls here and there can change things for the better...both for the game and for us. |
Of Course, They Would Have Had To Pay For My Plane Ticket ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Despite most state associations' working hard on improving sportsmanship, it seems like it isn't getting any better. A couple of things I have heard about inthe past couple of days:
1) the issues on this thread 2) In Minnesota, a coach being escorted out of the game by police. And this happened during a 5th grade tournament. We need to change culture if we ever want this to get better. As officials, I think we need to accept our share of the blame. Do we "T" up players we see finger wagging? Do we let coaches howl at us for an entire game, often outside of the coaching box? Do we not want to call the early handcheck because "it is a cheap foul" I will guarantee you that if we as officials started enforcing sportsmanship to the letter of the law much of this negative behavior would cease. A couple of ejections coupled with a couple of suspension should send the message that this type of behavior is not acceptable. Piggybacking on Billy's comments about where you work, I work exclusively rural games. If you put me in the middle of an inner city game, I would be like a fish out of water. |
Quote:
BillyMac nailed it on the head in his earlier post. Couldn't have said it better. |
Quote:
|
My officiating partner actually talked with one of the officials (lets call him Ralph) that did the game because they worked the Finals in Baseball a few years ago together. His take on the game was it was a black/white, rural/city thing from when the ball went up.
The Harrisburg kid that got a T said F'n N----- to the Setan Academy kid. So that warranted that T. Harrisburg coach, after being told what was said, said " I guess that warrants a T" and that was it. Sorry but if I am the coach I take him out and let him ride the pine until the end of the game. Doesnt matter who you are or what type of game it is. IMO Now for the Setan Academy kid that got kicked out, Ralph, who was the calling official, told my partner there was a little bit of a push from the Setan Academy kid, but since he put both hands on him he said it left him no choice but to give him the second T and eject him. If you guys thought that Saturday nights game was rough, you should have seen Harrisburg's game Friday night. That, in my opinion was much worse as far as roughness. |
Quote:
One more reason that crew was not ready for that kind of game. I hope just for their sake that is not true. Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I tossed a kid from a football game for that this year. Both players were black, and he was clearly trying to pick a fight with "what's up n----". Like Jeff, I've never seen a white kid use it, though. Right or wrong, there would be a faster hook in this case.
Makes me wonder if Ralph wasn't in a bit over his head. |
Quote:
We talk all the time about working places where you live and if you live in a town should you work a game with a local team? People make more assumptions about the racial composition of individuals than they do by where you live. I have worked recently at least one playoff game with a team in the town where I live and no one has said anything to me about my residence. But when I was working my first Sectional game with a Catholic school (not all white BTW) and an all-Black Community, I heard comments from both set of fans, one side assuming I was not from Chicago, the other assuming I was from Chicago and I was working with two Caucasian officials. Funny part for the 3 of us working that Sectional we all were used to that kind of game and dynamic on the game and one of my partners was a Chicago cop. But people assumed a lot based on the crew's racial mix and believe it or not, I got more crap from the Black community and coach than my partners did (which is typical but that is another conversation for another day). And I can tell you I came from rural, small town Illinois and that was a culture shock for me at first when I moved to the Chicago area. So if I had to adjust and learn that these games can be an extra challenge, you telling me officials that likely never sees that kind of game during the year all of a sudden is prepared for all the crap that could be said or done? I have said this before, there needs to be more diversity (not necessarily racial diversity) in the officials that work those games and this situation highlights that fact. There are officials in many parts of the state that would have done fine and probably would have put out some of those fires or at least ejected the damn kid for making such a statement. Peace |
Quote:
Now I need that second Dos Equis. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
The N Word ...
Quote:
It wasn't during the game, but the n word was used by Kemba Walker as he was being interviewed, surrounded by his teammates, after Connecticut won their most recent national championship. We all heard it. It's not too far of a stretch to think that we could hear something similar during our high school games. <iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/ARUhURiHThE" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> |
Context matters. In the case you bring up BillMac, not being used in deragatory manner or as racial slur, so I wouldnt touch in that situation.
|
I will tell you the difference. Go to the Southside of Chicago as a white person, Hispanic or someone clearly not apart of that group and see how many *** whoopins you have to avoid. Let me do the same thing and no one would bat an eye. It is really that simple.
Now I am not saying I like the usage fo the word and do not use it in mixed company, let alone inside people I like (I was raised by someone that did not like the word in any context). I often tell players not to use that word around me and I do not care if they are saying it to each other. But they will not use that word in my presence. Usually that sends a message and I do not hear it much. Also that is very rare and most players know that is not acceptable in many circles. They likely do not say that in a classroom. I use it as a teaching moment. Peace |
Quote:
I've mentioned in other posts we have a "no profanity" policy in the NYC Public Schools (another debate for another time) so when we give a quick mention about sportsmanship in the pre-game meeting we'll remind players in schools where it may be an issue "that includes the N-word." I can say I've yet to have a problem. |
I like the announcers in this video:
Renaldo Balkman banned for chokingteammate | SI Tracking Blog ? Tracking MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, and NCAA On Twitter |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
For what it's worth I was at the game. |
Becoming even bigger
|
I hope you are not surprised.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
While I don't mind publicizing names and even pictures; addresses and phone numbers? Really?
|
Quote:
Also I have worked a State Final in football with a school from the same town I was located. Never heard anything about it and I tell that story is how insignificant it can be. It is not a secret where we are from. Peace |
Quote:
Just an FYI, from a college standpoint the ECAC prohibits PA announcers from saying our names during the pre-game intros. My assignor got into arguments with some schools this season because they weren't complying. |
I gotta go with Rich...I'll take that chance.
|
Quote:
Just a curiosity question. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
In some state the names and towns in which an official resides is listed on their website. I am no expert, but doesn't the freedom of information act also make it possible to get this info? We are working for a state association who receives its money from the public. I think any resourceful person could acquire the info. |
Quote:
|
Not that it matters but for the one or two people who said these guys were in over their heads, these guys were at the final 4 last year as well. It seems like the state didn't think so.
This crew was selected over some IHSAA officials on this forum. |
Quote:
The state seems to have bigger issues with the conduct of the schools (players and coaches) than with the officiating. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I dont pretend to know all the people on this forum, not even all those from IL, but this is not necessarily so. This was a 2A championship game. In IL, we get to let the state know if we want to be considered for the 1a and 2a playoffs, the 3a and 4a playoffs, or both. Most of the people that I know from the Chicago area tell the IHSA that they are not interested in working 1a and 2a playoffs because they overlap with the playoffs for the bigger schools and they would rather do those. |
Quote:
Your above statement is not really true either. Since you referenced people on this site and I am one of them, I would not be assigned that level because I hardly ever do that level. I am lucky if I work 5 games with schools that small and if I do, it was because they were playing a bigger school in classification. And because we list the type of games we work throughout the year, I would not count a Seton game in most cases as a 1A-2A game. I believe we have to work at least 10 games at that level to be eligible for post season. I also have worked multiple Sectionals which also are the very same weekend of the this State Finals. If I am ever fortunate to work a State Final in basketball, at this time it would not be at the 1A-2A level. As Johnny said, most officials in this area would not be available for similar reasons as I am not normally available. I used to work smaller school playoffs but stopped getting those games as it appear to be clear where I was best served in the state's eyes and location of where I live. Peace |
I Know, I'm A Bad Boy ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I did in the last few years work with some friends near my home town, but we are talking well outside of Chicago and mostly an off day game to work any very small schools. I also work college so any other open dates those fill up my schedule. ;) Peace |
Follow Up
|
Quote:
He should get a five year ban for that tie......Good God |
Sounds like the superintendent needs some sort of discipline as well:
"I think everything Randy did was taken care of by the official, and it was normal basketball coaching behavior,” said Harrisburg superintendent Dennis Smith. “This is a make-up call for what Seton Academy did. The IHSA had to do something after releasing that initial statement so quickly. “Seton Academy’s behavior was despicable, and I am offended that our kids, coaches and school have been maligned because of it.” |
I'm sure that when the state association reads the supt's comments that they will be having a little chat.
|
Here's another article with a little more information.
'Ugly and embarrassing': IHSA levys sanctions against Harrisburg and Seton Academy | Boys Prep Basketball | News Democrat Obviously there was a heck of a lot that went on which we couldn't see on the broadcast. As far as the officials go, we all discussed it earlier in the thread: Be prepared. The crew for this game looked as though it was struggling from the start. |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
So which is it? |
Quote:
And the funny part about all this, the Harrisburg coach got off easy. He was put on probation, not suspended. The Seton Coach was suspended during the post season for 2 years. And unless I missed something that was not negotiable. Peace |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:48am. |