T or no T?

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by jeremy341a

Should I have given a T to H2 for his good defence comment as it was another attack on my partner's call.

Hell no. I suspect it's more likely H2 was trying to ground H1 rather than making a sideways comment to your partner, who wasn't even there to hear it. Too sensitive by several degrees.

[jeremy341a]

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn

Hell no. I suspect it's more likely H2 was trying to ground H1 rather than making a sideways comment to your partner, who wasn't even there to hear it. Too sensitive by several degrees.

H2 wasn't trying to ground H1 as H2 was the only one to complain even though the fould was on H1. Also H2 never complained to the calling official only myself. He most definetly said it as if to say you didn't foul, you got screwed.

[Tio]

This is a good situation where a pair of "earmuffs" come in handy. Just ignore him... he is obviously frustrated with the call. I think the only mistake you made is trying to explain that your partner had a good look. Maybe he didn't??? i would just tell the kid it was a tough play and to talk to your partner about it. I stay out of it as the non-calling official.

[jeremy341a]

Originally Posted by Tio

This is a good situation where a pair of "earmuffs" come in handy. Just ignore him... he is obviously frustrated with the call. I think the only mistake you made is trying to explain that your partner had a good look. Maybe he didn't??? i would just tell the kid it was a tough play and to talk to your partner about it. I stay out of it as the non-calling official.

Point taken. The player complaining wasn't the player to which the foul was called.

[Tio]

Yeah... sometimes you get the "big brother" player who is going to stick up for his teammates. Again, I think you can ignore this one and move on.

[zm1283]

Originally Posted by tomegun

I know we have some other baseball guys on this board. Do you do the same thing? I am looking at this as either hyperbole or kind of a foul (pun intended) practice. If a ball is extremely outside, would you still call it a strike?

As MD said, the "old school" way to handle a player pissing and moaning was the "f*** you call" where you would call a strike on a pitch that wasn't really a strike. That is generally discouraged now, and there are other ways to handle it. If a batter hasn't said anything else and just says "You missed that one" like egj13 was talking about, it doesn't even get a response from me, especially at the college level. If he is persistent or tries to show you up, you can walk in front of the plate and brush it off and talk to him with your mask on. Same with the catcher if he is giving you trouble.