![]() |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
You told a poster in order for the play to be legal you need to consider McGrady's throw off the backboard "a try". Why does he need to consider it a try when it's perfectly legal to throw the ball off your own backboard and retrieve it? Why add judgment to a play that doesn't need judgment? |
Quote:
But what's the problem with calling it a try? Player threw the ball which hit the board and was subsequently rebounded by him or some other player. For all intents and purposes, it was a try. |
Quote:
When given the choice of "cut and dry" vs. "judgment and condsideration", I prefer the former. |
Quote:
And it cannot be a legal try. If a A1 is fouled while throwing the ball off the opposing backboard or accidentally tries for a basket, it does not warrant free-throws. It would just be a throw-in at the spot closest to the spot of the foul. That just led me to a question though... what if the ball goes into the wrong basket when a player, in shooting motion, is fouled? I think this is dead ball and the basket doesn't count, but may need someone to confirm that. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
But, your wording, while I knew what you meant with your question, could be twisted such that it was asking something entirely different. So, let's do so just a bit to have some fun... What if, with 2 seconds left on the clock, A1 attempts to heave a 75 foot shot from the backcourt FT lane but in doing so gets fouled such that the ball is deflected directly into the wrong basket. I know this will not happen, but what if it did....what would you rule? |
Quote:
But, If your scenario went like this: try , deflection of ball back into basket, foul, horn. I just opened another can of worms. Going to count the points for the made "wrong" basket, then 3 fts to the original player with lanes cleared. Isn't this fun? :D |
Quote:
How could it be a shooting foul if the foul occurs after the ball is deflected into the wrong basket? And why did you clear the lane? |
Quote:
What do you think, Camron? |
Quote:
Quote:
But, to keep this going, I'm going to say this, however I'm only guessing and have no idea what would be right or wrong... wrong basket is good off the deflection, foul is no longer a shooting foul because the ball has entered the opposing basket legally, making that play dead. If time was still on the clock at the point the foul occurred according to one of the officials, put time back on the clock and take the ball OOB closest to the spot of the foul. |
Quote:
2. If a player is fouled while shooting towards his opponent's basket, that is not a shooting foul, and free throws are only granted if the bonus is in effect. |
Quote:
The lane is cleared because time expired as the foul was committed. End of period so lanes cleared. All of this is extremely hypothetical and pretty much impossible but what if... |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:47am. |