![]() |
Call on the court = Play on. Doris Burke agreed :) What's your opinion?
<iframe width="853" height="480" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/GPUsATDJW0M?rel=0" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
|
Looks like a charge. Defender doesn't do anything wrong.
|
No problem with the playon here. The defender clearly leans( surpasses verticality) into the path of the ball handler after she is airborne.
The question I have is. Where is the T? |
Quote:
High Altitude got the T bending over full court, huffing and puffing. :D |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Now, after seeing it in slow motion a few times, I changed my mind. The defender's lean creates contact. Had she remained vertical, the shooter would have landed short of contact, IMO. I'd like to think I would got it right on the court, but I don't know. I don't give a rats a$$ what Burke thinks, though. Altitude? In Denver? Pshaw! |
Cant say that I liked the no call as the defender clearly (obvious) leans forward into the shooter.
As I look deeper at the "whys" I can understand the no call. Steal in the b/c probably has the old new L (now the new T) somewhere around the division line. Tough to get back when busting it to the other end that quickly! The C has no look whatsoever & the L is set up good for lateral movement. Good discipline by the crew. |
Who is Doris Burke? Is that someone who I should know?
|
Defender does lean forward to create what is really minor contact but does not disadvantage the shooter in any way....no call OK, but a block would be OK too.
|
The defender never stops coming forward. I have a block, but I do not think on this kind of play you can have a no-call. And I am a person that usually judges these plays as charges as a default, but the defender clearly did not stop coming forward from this angle.
Peace |
Quote:
|
I think I'd go with a block here but could see a no call.
|
I like the no-call here. Defender leaned out of vertical plane to create contact. The L seems to have best view and positioning here. If she saw the lean and opted to pass on the whistle, that's a pretty good piece of officiating IMHO.
P.S. Whatever Doris Burke says...the opposite is usually true. I'd like to watch a game with her and Clark Kellog doing commentary. They could conceivably get EVERY whistle wrong between the two of them. |
This is a no-call or a block.
I don't like these types of leans, so I tend to call a block. But at the higher levels, this is easily a no-call. |
Quote:
Peace |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:14pm. |